The Origin of Weird: Rube Waddell
A pitcher so dominant he rewrote the strikeout leaderboard, and so unpredictable he could be lured off the mound by a puppy in the stands. We’re Bradley and Kate, and we’re telling the story of George “Rube” Waddell, a Deadball Era icon whose MLB greatness and total chaos somehow coexist in the same box score.
We dig into Rube’s rise from a Pennsylvania farm kid with a cannon arm to one of baseball history’s most feared left-handed pitchers, including his jaw-dropping 349 strikeouts in 1904 and the elite earned run average that still puts him in rare company. We also track the teams that shaped his career, from early stops to Connie Mack’s Philadelphia Athletics, plus the twists that made him a legend long after his final pitch.
Then the weirdness takes over: his fire-truck obsession, the stories of leaving games to help fight fires, and the animal-filled life that included everything from bears to the not-quite-disproven jump-rope geese. There’s even a Wisconsin chapter with the early Milwaukee Brewers and Pewaukee Lake, where fishing mattered enough for Rube to vanish for days while professional baseball waited. We close with the hard edge of the tale: fights, drinking, the heroic flood sandbagging near the Mississippi River, and the illness that took him at just 37, followed by his Hall of Fame induction in 1946.
If you love baseball history, quirky sports legends, and true stories that sound made up, queue this one up now. Subscribe for more, share it with a friend who loves weird history, and leave a rating and review so more listeners can find us.
This website contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and purchase a product, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the running of this website and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Please note that I only recommend products and services that I believe in and have personally used or researched.
00:00 - Late Drop And Quick Apology
00:56 - The Pitch Caught In A Shirt
01:44 - Meet Rube Waddell
03:14 - Farm Boy To Strikeout Machine
05:59 - Fire Trucks Over Baseball
07:59 - Bears Geese And Dugout Chaos
11:33 - Milwaukee And Pewaukee Lake Fishing
14:21 - Connie Mack Tries To Contain Him
16:28 - Flood Heroics Then A Fast Decline
18:43 - Teams Legacy And How To Reach Us
Late Drop And Quick Apology
SPEAKER_01Oh hey there.
SPEAKER_00Oh hey there.
SPEAKER_01How are you today?
SPEAKER_00I'm good. How are you?
SPEAKER_01I am well. Go Bradley. I'm Kate. This is the origin of weird. By the history buffoons. Uh we had a little bit of a scheduling conflict, so this is uh Whoopsie Daisy so uh day late. Our apologies, and uh that's okay. Our bad. Well, life happens, right? Yeah. It's not our fault.
SPEAKER_00I have one.
The Pitch Caught In A Shirt
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you have a life too. Yeah. I got two little lives. Vesper and Xavier. Yeah, it was a busy week, so so it goes. What do you got that's weird for us today? On the origin of weird.
SPEAKER_00A baseball pitcher.
SPEAKER_01Pitcher. Yes. Did you see the clip the other day? Um, this guy, I don't remember what the teams were that were playing. A pitcher threw a pitch, guy hit it directly at the pitcher. Came off his bat, I think they said at uh 107.8 miles per hour. He caught it in a shirt. He caught it in the shirt? It went right through the buttons and everything, and he caught it in a shirt. Whoa! It was crazy.
SPEAKER_00Do you think he's got bruises?
Meet Rube Waddell
SPEAKER_01I don't I don't know if it like ricocheted off his stomach or anything, but I so he was like sitting sideways, like did it come through and he was, you know, how they get in their motion and everything and they land, and then he stood up and it went right into his shirt. Anyways. Baseball pitcher, huh?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, we're gonna talk about George Edward Waddell.
SPEAKER_01Waddell?
SPEAKER_00Or I'm gonna call him. Everybody calls him Rube.
SPEAKER_01Rube. What year? Rube Waddell. What year did Rube? No, was this in the Major Leagues pitcher?
SPEAKER_00He was yes, he was in the major leagues. Yeah. So we're talking late 1800s, early 1900s.
SPEAKER_01Is this the guy who created the curveball?
SPEAKER_00No, not that no, I didn't read that. Okay. Yeah. He had a curveball.
Farm Boy To Strikeout Machine
SPEAKER_01Right. But I don't remember what year it was, and I pissed that I don't remember the name of the pitcher, but it was like late 1800s. Okay. And pretty much pitchers back then always just um you start a game, you finish it. It wasn't like all the relief pitchers like we have today, no pitch counts, nothing like that. And it was just throw the ball as fast as you can over the plate. Right. And this one guy, I'll have to look this up because now it's irritating me. I don't remember his name. But he learned that like if he held it a certain way, yeah, holy shit, it just dropped. Yeah. And everyone was just like, that's legal, you know, because people fear change. But it wasn't. But um, and then of course, like he like drastically changed the way baseball was played because now it's not just get it over to play, wish for your best. Because you know, people get over. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00So so Rube Waddell was born Friday, October 5th, 13th. Friday, October the 13th. Oh dear. In 1876 in Bradford, Pennsylvania. Okay. He grew up on a farm where he developed his pitching arm by throwing rocks at birds to keep them away from the crops.
SPEAKER_01Oh. So he was like the family scarecrow?
SPEAKER_00Pretty much, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Just more mobile.
SPEAKER_00Mobile. More alive. I have all right. Anyway. Wow. By the time he was a young adult, he had a fastball that was pretty fucking overwhelming for hitters.
SPEAKER_02Sure.
SPEAKER_00He ended up at a small college college where he barely attended class.
SPEAKER_01Because he was just there to play baseball?
SPEAKER_00He yeah, he wanted to play baseball.
SPEAKER_01It sounds like sports players today, they barely go to class because they're there for sports. Yeah. Because it's a money-making business.
SPEAKER_00He struck out hitters constantly. Okay. And he could control games by himself. Sure. Um, there was even a point where a rival town reportedly kidnapped him. Okay. I read once that it was at gunpoint, and I read another time where they just kind of strong armed him.
SPEAKER_01So you're coming with us.
SPEAKER_00Pretty much. They said, We're you're not pitching against us, you're gonna pitch for us. And he did. He went through with it. He's like, he don't care. He's just here to play.
SPEAKER_01Do you pay the same?
SPEAKER_00So once he reached the majors um uh from the early 1900s, he led the league in strikeouts year after year. In 1904, he racked up 349 strikeouts. Holy crap. Mm-hmm. And it was a number that stood for decades until uh for left-handed pitchers, which he was.
SPEAKER_01Oh, he was a southpaw? Holy shit.
SPEAKER_00Until Sandy Koufax. Great fucking ball player from the 50s and 60s eventually passed it.
SPEAKER_01He was amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um that's a question I was just gonna ask about Rube. You said 394 strikeouts that year, right?
SPEAKER_00Three 349.
SPEAKER_01Oh, 49. My dyslexia kicked in. Dyslexia? Um did it say how many games he played?
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01No. Okay. Continue.
Fire Trucks Over Baseball
SPEAKER_00So his career ERA Which is stands for Earned Runs Average. Yeah. Um, it sits sits among the best in baseball history. Wow. Um, his numbers would hold up against other legends. So on paper, he's one of like the more dominant pitchers of his era. Sure. But uh Rube was weird. Well, I mean he was weird. Rube. He was a little obsessed with fire trucks. You saw that coming, didn't you? Saw it coming.
SPEAKER_01How old how old was this pitcher?
SPEAKER_00No, he um, I think he got to the major leagues just before he turned 21.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow, that's pretty young though. Yeah. I mean, that's crazy.
SPEAKER_00Um, but as a kid, he would wander off and end up sleeping in fire stations. Um, if a fire truck went by during a game that he was at, there was a legitimate chance that he would just leave the game to go after the fire truck.
SPEAKER_01What the fuck? Why?
SPEAKER_00Um, I think he wanted to help.
SPEAKER_01I would be your backup.
SPEAKER_00He's like so.
SPEAKER_01Can I be your Dalmatian?
SPEAKER_00At times he would wear like a red shirt under his uniform so that he could strip down quickly and jump into action if needed. Oh my god. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So he's a great baseball player, but yeah, apparently his passion was firefighting. Firefighting. Wow.
SPEAKER_00Um, there are accounts of him him leaving games mid-play to go help the fires. At one point during a game, a mattress, which I'm not really sure why it was there, but a mattress behind home plate caught fire. Likely from someone smoking in the stands, and while everyone else was reacting like normal humans, he grabbed it, dragged it onto the field, and just handled it there. Well, like it was part of his job description. Naturally. He also had this instinct to help people even when it didn't quite go according to plan.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_00At one point he jumped off of a ferry in the Del Delaware River to rescue what he thought was a drowning woman. He swam out fully committed, only to realize that he risked his life for a floating log. Still E for effort.
SPEAKER_01Did he did he keep the log? Should have carved it into something. Maybe a bat.
Bears Geese And Dugout Chaos
SPEAKER_00And then Rube loved animals. Okay. Um, he owned multiple bears. Bears? Yep. There weren't really rules about wild animals back then. In the Ought Force. Give or take. He had dogs and pigs and a flock of geese that he reportedly trained how to jump rope, and that was never disproven.
SPEAKER_01Was it also ever proven? Okay. Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_00But it wasn't disproven either.
SPEAKER_01We'll take your word, Rube. What the fuck? Why would you want a jump roping geese? Flock a geese.
SPEAKER_00So I looked this up and I was like, please explain this.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, but on Wikipedia it says something along the lines of one time there was a geese that couldn't jump rope, so he just gave him the rope. And so he the duck held the rope, or the geese or whatever held the rope for him.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god.
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_01What the fuck?
SPEAKER_00Um opposing teams learned real quickly that if you wanted to distract Rube, you didn't need any strategy. You needed a puppy. Or a fire truck.
SPEAKER_01What would happen if a puppy was on a fire truck?
unknownOoh.
SPEAKER_01Fucking double whammy.
SPEAKER_00Fans would hold up dogs in the stands, and Rube would completely lose focus and wander over and try to interact with the dogs.
SPEAKER_01So is this like the original take your dog uh bark at the park, they call it? What the fuck? Hold on, guys. There's a puppy over there. Oh, you're so cute. I mean, what the shit? I mean, I like dogs too, but damn.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00So on the mound, he would actually some c sometimes call off his outfielders, like say, you don't need to come out here because I'm just gonna strike everyone out.
SPEAKER_01Oh, but that's not how the game works. But okay.
SPEAKER_00Well, in the 1900s, we were I mean, I guess. Um sometimes that happened. He stroke everybody out, and sometimes it did not.
SPEAKER_01So did he have to go running for the ball then?
SPEAKER_00I mean kind of, right?
SPEAKER_01That means if I was the man what team did he play for? Did you ever get there?
SPEAKER_00I do. Um his manager was Connie Mack. Cornelius.
SPEAKER_01The name sounds familiar. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Cornelius McGillis or so. Cornelius McGillicuddy. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01So what team?
SPEAKER_00Um he jumped around a little bit, um, but I'll I'll I'll list him at the end. Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_01Because like, if I was that manager, hey uh him hey hey, Skip. Rube just said we don't need to go out there, I'd be like, get your fucking ass out there. Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_00Rube is not the manager.
SPEAKER_01No, exactly. And that's my point is like, um Rube doesn't tell you what to do, I tell you what to do.
SPEAKER_00But he would also like ignore the catcher, so there would be wild pitches and missed signals and the chaos because they wouldn't listen to the catcher. Of course. Um, he made animal noises at hitters, he would change his delivery. I'm not sure what kind of delivery, like mid-game. He would do cartwheels off the mound. Did he play for the Savannah Bananas? My next line literally says it's the late 1800s version of the Savannah Bananas. What the fuck?
SPEAKER_01That's literally what I wrote in. Oh man, I still want to go see them. If they ever come to town and the prices aren't ridiculous, we should go see them.
SPEAKER_00The waiting list is super long.
Milwaukee And Pewaukee Lake Fishing
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know, which sucks.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so now we're in the middle of all this, and Rube actually had a brief connection to Wisconsin.
SPEAKER_01Oh, how so?
SPEAKER_00Um, he played for a little bit on the Milwaukee Brewers, who were a minor league at the time.
SPEAKER_01We had a minor league team called the Milwaukee Brewers.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's what I said.
SPEAKER_01Are you sure? Are you sure that's right? It's what I wrote. Doesn't mean it's right.
SPEAKER_00Was it supposed to be the Braves?
SPEAKER_01The Milwaukee Braves was the major league team.
SPEAKER_00So, yeah, this was a minor league team at the time.
SPEAKER_01In like the 50s. So that that's well before or well after Rube would have been.
SPEAKER_00Maybe I made that up.
SPEAKER_01I I feel like we're gonna fact check this.
SPEAKER_00So around 1900, 1901, Milwaukee had a team called the Brewers in the American League. In 1901, the league became a major league. That specific Brewers team then moved to St. Louis and became the Browns.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, they played at Borchirk Field.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so he was a Brewer.
SPEAKER_01I I never knew we had a minor league team in the early 1900s to call them one. I've never heard that before. That's crazy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So also Yes. He liked he really loved playing in Milwaukee.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Because there's lots of puppies.
SPEAKER_00No. Because there was a lake that he would frequent to go fishing. He became attached to Pewkey Lake.
SPEAKER_01Hey, that's where I'm from. I know. I swam in that lake where Rube used to fish.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01That's fucking crazy.
SPEAKER_00I was researching this guy not knowing the Wisconsin connection. Yeah. And I was like, oh shit.
SPEAKER_01That's kind of cool. Yeah. Really? Yeah. That's so fucking weird.
SPEAKER_00So um that lake actually started becoming a little bit interfering with his career. Okay. Um, he would disappear for days at a time. No one knew where he was, no way to reach him, and the team would just have to wait for him. And eventually someone would figure out that he was on Pewkey Lake fishing, completely unbothered by the fact that he was supposed to be pitching in professional baseball games.
SPEAKER_01That's crazy. That is so weird.
SPEAKER_00There was even a situation where he joined a local team because they offered him a deal that allowed him to fish six days a week.
SPEAKER_01All right, here's the deal. You play one day, you sick, fish six. Fish six. Sign me up. That's funny. Wow.
Connie Mack Tries To Contain Him
SPEAKER_00He would have like long stretches on the water, completely checked out from anything else, no concern for consequences. Um, and this is where Connie Matt comes in. Um, his manager. Yeah. He had to get creative uh to keep Rube engaged.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00At one point, he made him, quote, captain of the balls, which it meant that he had to hand out baseballs and chase them down.
SPEAKER_01Sure did. So he was like a professional uh ball boy in a way for the team, like, but on the team at the same time.
SPEAKER_00So we would keep him on the field, and um sometimes it worked, and sometimes he would still leave.
SPEAKER_01At what point does Connie Mac or any other person in this league go, We should maybe move on?
SPEAKER_00They do. They it eventually they move on.
SPEAKER_01Of course, but do you think one person is just like, but skip? He throws a lot of strikeouts or fastballs or whatever you want to say. It's like that's just fucking weird.
SPEAKER_00So Rube would miss practices constantly, disappearing during road trips, show up late or not at all. Um, there was a story where a team scheduled a game expecting thousands of fans to show up just to see Rube pitch, and he didn't show. Not because he forgot, though, because he went to the wrong stadium. He's wandering around like, where is everybody?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm here. I'll just throw. I'll just collect some balls.
SPEAKER_00Um, he did have a habit of getting into fights, uh, sometimes with fans, sometimes with other players. Um, he once vaulted into the stand and grabbed a Heckler mid-game, shook him, and then calmly returned to the mountain pitch like nothing had happened.
SPEAKER_01What the fuck?
Flood Heroics Then A Fast Decline
SPEAKER_00Um, yes. Um, but unfortunately Rube also drank heavily. Oh dear. It was part of his reputation. Um, and fans would chant about it during games. His managers would try to intervene, sometimes in bizarre ways, but there was um a few moments in his personal life where uh violence in relationships started happening. Okay, but later in life, he became became a little bit more heroic.
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_00Um, living near the Mississippi River, um, a town faced severe flooding, and he worked for days helping build up levees and um sandbagging without rush, rest, pushing himself far beyond what was considered safe. Sure. Um, but after that, he actually did develop pneumonia and tuberculosis, and his health declined pretty rapidly.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00And he died at just 37 years old.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow. He did all that nonsense in 37 years old.
SPEAKER_00And died at 37 years old. He died. April Fool's Day, April 1st, 1914.
SPEAKER_01Maybe. Maybe cheer me out here. Maybe he really didn't die. He just told everyone he did, and he went fishing.
SPEAKER_00Um Rube Waddell was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946.
SPEAKER_01Oh, was he really? So he's actually in the Hall of Fame? He is, yeah. Wow, that's crazy.
SPEAKER_00So for the National League, he started off with the Louisville um colonels.
SPEAKER_01Colonels, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Then he went on to the Pittsburgh Pirates for a year.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And then the Chicago Orphans for a year, 1901.
SPEAKER_01Then they took the train out of there.
SPEAKER_00I know, right?
SPEAKER_01Weird.
SPEAKER_00Um, then he was on the American League on the Philadelphia Athletics from 1902 to 1907.
SPEAKER_01Do you know who who they are now?
SPEAKER_00Athletics.
SPEAKER_01That's the team moving to Vegas.
SPEAKER_00Vegas, oh, okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because they moved out to Oakland and now they're they're homeless currently until their stadium is built in Vegas, but that's the team that's moving there.
SPEAKER_00Um, and then from 1908 to 1910, he was um the St. Louis Browns.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And then um he had a very short stint um as a Detroit Tiger in 1910.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow. So what year did he die? Did you say that? 1914. 1914. Was the Detroit Tigers the last team that he played for? Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Well, the last major league anyway.
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah. Yeah. Right, right. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Rube Waddell, crazy, crazy kooky guy.
Teams Legacy And How To Reach Us
SPEAKER_01Rube Waddell. Can honestly say I never heard of him. Kind of like the fact that he used to fish on the lake that I grew up on. That's pretty awesome.
SPEAKER_00And he was a brewer.
SPEAKER_01He was technically a brewer. That I I never knew we had a minor league team in the early 1900s called that.
SPEAKER_02That's yeah.
SPEAKER_01Now I'm kind of I like our team name, but now I'm like, oh, way to get creative, Bud Seagull. Seal Sealeg. Wow, I almost said Seagull.
SPEAKER_00Sea leg.
SPEAKER_01He was the guy who brought the brewers to Wisconsin. He also was the baseball commissioner for a really long time. And then he let his daughter run the team, and then she did a really good job at running it into the ground. Uh-oh. And make us not competitive for a long time. And then uh they finally sold the team to Mark Antanazio, and now we're consistently a I'll say a good team. But man, I really just want to fucking win a World Series.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
unknownSomeday.
SPEAKER_01I hope before I die.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So clocks ticking, brewers. Well, I suppose. Alright, buffoons, that's it for today's episode.
SPEAKER_00Buckle up because we've got another historical adventure waiting for you next time. Feeling hungry for more buffoonery? Or maybe you have a burning question or a wild historical theory for us to explore?
SPEAKER_01Hit us up on social media. We're History Buffoons Podcast on YouTube, X, Instagram, and Facebook. You can also email us at history buffoonspodcast at gmail.com. We are Bradley and Kate, music by Corey Akers.
SPEAKER_00Follow us wherever you get your podcasts and turn those notifications on to stay in the loop.
SPEAKER_01Until next time, stay curious and don't forget to rate and review us.
SPEAKER_00Remember, the buffoonery never stops.






