It Started Running: Lizzie Cyr/Famous 5 Part 1
The fascinating case of Lizzie Cyr begins with a simple arrest for "vagrancy" in 1917 Calgary and transforms into a landmark legal battle that would permanently alter women's rights in Canada.
When Lizzie Cyr, a 29-year-old woman of First Nations and European heritage, found herself homeless and accepted temporary lodging from an acquaintance named John James Ryan, she unknowingly stepped into legal history. After Ryan paid her for sex, claimed she infected him with gonorrhea, and attempted to blackmail her for medicine money, Cyr found herself arrested and standing before one of Canada's first female magistrates, Alice Jameson.
Enter John McKinley Cameron, Cyr's eccentric lawyer known for representing society's most marginalized people. With his trademark mismatched suits and sometimes rubber boots, Cameron skillfully exposed Ryan's hypocrisy during cross-examination, revealing that Ryan regularly visited sex workers and had contracted gonorrhea before. Despite this compelling defense, Magistrate Jameson abruptly sentenced Cyr to six months hard labor without allowing her to testify.
What happened next would change Canadian legal history forever. Rather than simply appealing the verdict, Cameron pursued a bold strategy – challenging Jameson's very right to serve as a magistrate on the grounds that women couldn't legally hold such positions. This challenge reached the Alberta Supreme Court, where Justice Stewart declared "in our province and in our time there is no legal reason to disqualify women from holding public office," making Alberta the first Canadian province to officially recognize women as legal persons with the right to hold public office.
While Lizzie Cyr disappeared from historical records after serving her sentence, her case became crucial in establishing women's legal personhood – a concept that would be further developed in the "Famous Five" case detailed in next week's episode. Join us for the conclusion of this unexpected legal journey that helped secure fundamental rights for Canadian women.
The Person Behind the Persons Case Written by Sarah Burton
http://canadashistory.ca/explore/women/the-person-behind-the-persons-case
This website contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and purchase a product, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the running of this website and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Please note that I only recommend products and services that I believe in and have personally used or researched.
00:16 - Meet the History Buffoons
01:05 - Beer Tasting and Brewery Talk
06:50 - Introducing Lizzie Sear's Story
10:42 - The Arrest and Ryan's Accusations
17:44 - The Courtroom Confrontation
28:07 - Challenging a Female Magistrate's Authority
38:44 - The Legal Ruling and Historical Impact
46:36 - Setting Up Part Two and Wrap-Up
0:16 Oh, hey there, oh hey there, I'm Kate. And I'm Bradley and we are the History Buffoons. That's right, yes, yes. Yes. How are you? I'm well, how are you? I's right? Yes, yes, yes. How are you? I'm well, how are you? I'm good. Yeah, yeah, excellent. Yeah, it's kind of a long week, but yeah, it felt like it. Yeah, but you know, we made it through. We sure did. On to record another episode. Why is that funny? another episode. Why is that funny? Um, because I killed it this week. Yeah, yeah, how so? Do tell lots of research, yes, lots of writing yeah just I killed it what is it?
0:59 writing for our podcast I know, I was joking yes, I, I killed it. All right. I'm also excited because you surprised me with a beer. I did so. As we've said hi Penny, multiple times on this podcast, I like to drink Limey's Summer Shandy. It's my go-to everyday beer and we were picking out podcast beers a week or two ago and we saw that Lainey's has a new Lainey Lodge, lime. Lainey Kugel has a Lainey Lodge Lime and it's a bright lime green can and I love it. And tell them the style of beer that it is.
1:41 It is a Mexican-style lager with natural lime flavor. Yeah, which is right up your alley, because you love your medellos I sure do with a lime typically so and, if you didn't know, line of kugel is from milwaukee well, it's from chippewa falls, but they just actually it's from chippewa falls and also milwaukee so they just recently apparently I saw something on this they just recently closed operations down at the original brewery. Really, I believe I saw that? Oh, so are they just full-time in Milwaukee now. Yeah, but they're from up in Chippewa Falls, so the Limey Lodge, which is their store and beer room, and everything is still there.
2:23 However, apparently they don't brew any beer out of there anymore is what I saw. I think that's right. I didn't look into it what kind of beer do you have? oh dear. I got caught on my quad so I have a beer. That's been long awaiting to try. Oh, okay, didn't have to interrupt, but here we are. So, as you know, our first fan, Al Al. He is still in the beer business. That's where he and I met many, many, many, many, many years ago, and he currently lives out in Nevada and he works for a couple breweries that he's part of, I guess, and one of them is Avery, and they have a Maharaja IPA.
3:09 He told me, because he knows I like IPAs, that I should try this, and then I went to the store. Couldn't find it. Couldn't find it. Ooh, I found it. Holy balls, it's almost 15 bucks a six pack, holy crap. So the first time I saw it, I'm like I'm going to wait. I guess I just wasn't prepared to spend $15 on a six pack at that time it better be good. However, this week I was prepared, apparently because I currently have a six pack here. Maharaja. Maharaja, and so it's an Imperial India Pale Ale 10%. Holy schmuckies. Yeah, so I have two of these queued up. I have two Linen Kugels queued up.
3:51 I might be feeling a little saucy at the end of this episode. So thanks for the suggestion, al. Here we go, oh, yes, yes, oh my gosh, I can't wait for this. I'll let you try it first. Usually we choose each other, but oh yeah, cheers, I'll have another sip. It's pretty good, can you, is it? it's not too limey no, that's not too limey. I still prefer modelo, sure, but this is a great little substitute. Okay, I like it. There you go yeah, I will keep drinking it, for sure it will not go to waste, I promise you? Yeah, I will keep drinking it for sure it will not go to waste. I promise you. Yeah, At least keep drinking it until all six are gone. Yeah absolutely, yeah, absolutely.
4:32 Yeah, absolutely. I think that's our new term. Yeah, absolutely All the kitties are put away except for Penny and Amos. That's really good. Oh, yeah, yeah, Hold for uh penny and amos. That's really good. Oh yeah yeah, hold on while I take a second sip worth the 15 yes, thanks al. Uh, great choice, or a suggestion? Um, the funny thing is I told him how much I got it for and he's like that's a great price. Oh wow, but he also lives out in nevada so not sure what the pricing is out there. Yeah, definitely could be a little higher, but that's really good. So it is now like mid-afternoon.
5:14 Yes. And Amos is pretty on the dot when it comes. Well, actually, he's really not. He's fairly early when it comes to wanting to be fed and he is the most vocal out of all five of them put together. Oh, hands, all of them put together. I've been over to your house close to feeding time. I swear he yells at me. It's what he's doing, oh my God. He walks around and just yells, and then he'll walk up to you and yell. Yeah. So to say he's the most vocal is an understatement yeah, but like you can't really pick him up or like snuggle him because and he's a scaredy cat, he's like the quintessential scaredy cat yeah, that's pretty much.
5:56 If he was alive when they created that term, they would show a picture of him. Yeah, he would be in the dictionary as Scaredy Cat aka Amos, so if he interrupts us during this, that is why it's almost dinner time. That's all right, we'll make do. Yeah, okay, I want one more drink before we move on to this, sorry. I'm glad you like it, though I know you said you like your Medela better, but I'm glad you're enjoying it. It's got a limey taste like like your summer shandy. Sure it does have that, but yeah, they, they have obviously a distinct kind of process and now that it's all uh macro through milwaukee, which is unfortunate. I liked it better when they were just up in the chippewa falls.
6:38 But yeah they've been brewing them down in milwaukee for some time, so that's also why summer shandy's year round nowadays. So okay, you're ready for this I'm ready for this. Let's do this okay, so this story came from nathan. Okay, he heard it off of the tv show letter kenny I know of it. I've never watched it same yeah, he finds it absolutely hilarious I think it was my brother, one or both my brothers, unless I'm mixing up a show, but yeah, I've heard and I think it's a Canadian show, I believe that's correct. Yes, so for some reason this Canadian comedy show talked about a particular story.
7:22 Okay. And I'm going to talk about it today. Okay, Well, I kind of gathered that. Based on my intro. Yes, okay, good. Yes, I did the thing you did something. Okay, so we are going to talk about Lizzie Sear. Sear Like S-E-E-R. No, her last name is spelled completely different okay her last name is spelled c-y-r. Oh sure yeah lizzie seer. Okay, so not much is known about her other than through her arrest records is she canadian too? she is, so you're to tell me what's all about her.
8:03 What's all about? What's it all about? So she was 5'6". Brown eyes, dark complexion. She was born in Canada. She has First Nations and European heritage. She was born in 1888. 1888, wow. So at the time of our story she was 29 years old. That's two stories in a row that you mentioned 1888. Why88, wow, so at the time of our story she was 29 years old. That's two stories in a row that you mentioned 1888. Why do you have the memory that you do? Oh my God. The funny thing is you meant to say 1889. 1888. Okay, this is, I'm going to show you a picture of Lizzie Sear. She's supposed to be 28. I mean she is 28. Wait, she's 28 in that picture, but doesn't she look like the unsinkable Molly Brown or something.
8:48 She looks like she was rode hard and put away wet for sure, Holy balls. Yeah, and she does look like the unsinkable Molly. Brown, she does. Wasn't she like 60, though, or something like that she's 29. Actually, she was probably 40, but that was 1912. Actually, she was probably 40, but that was 1912. Yeah, wow, okay, so her occupation. In her arrest record said wife, okay, and she was arrested for being a wife. Vagrancy. Oh, she was a vagrant. They called sex workers vagrants at that time. Oh okay so she was arrested for vagrancy Gotcha. Okay, so her vagrancy had a vacancy. Did she like to fill it?
9:29 Wow, wow. Wow. Podcast gold. Are you sure? Nope, okay, actually, I'm pretty sure it's the opposite. Pretty sure it's turning my finger. Gold I mean green. Here on History, buffoon's podcast. It's turning my ears green. There it is Wow Okay. It's more like some fool's gold over there Super fool. Okay, the guy who basically got arrested. His name is John James Ryan, so is that how? they got a John as the name.
10:09 Okay. John James, he's starting early. Oh hey, dinner time. I mean it's not, but dinner time. So he gets her arrested on May 17th 1917. Okay. They did know each other for a while, and just a few days before this arrest she was down on her luck. She had no money, nowhere to go, and because they knew each other, he let her stay at his place. So if she was listed as wife, where was her husband? They were getting a divorce. I believe. So they were estranged, yeah, in a way. So, okay, fine he. So they were estranged. Yeah, Okay, fine, he lets her stay right. Sure, yeah, and then he pays her $10 to make a holla.
10:54 Yeah, wait, make him holla. Whatever Doesn't matter, no judgment. But she gets sick the next day. Oh dear. And so she's stuck at his place for another night, essentially. Oh man, so another $10? . By Sunday, though. John James Ryan how boring of a name, I mean pretty. I know Pretty. By Sunday, he's had enough, and he kicks her out. Okay, a few by Sunday, he's had enough, and he kicks her out. Okay, a few days later he gets sick. Oh dear. Of the Rhea. The Ghana.
11:35 The Ghana of the Rhea. Wow, that sucks. He has gonorrhea. Well, I bet she does too. And of course he blames Lizzie. Well, why wouldn't he? but you know what he's had, this fucking disease before yeah, it's probably from him, yeah and instead of going to the doctor, he goes straight to the drugstore that's weird and then he tries to blackmail her. Okay, if you pay for my meds, I won't call the cops. But so I'm confused. What is he calling the cops on, though? Vagrancy? I mean, that seems kind of loose at this point. Ba-dum-bum, thank you, glad you got that, but you know what I mean.
12:17 Well, she tells him where to go Straight to H-E-double hockey sticks, hey. We're a family show and he calls the cops on her of course so they grab her that afternoon and she's literally got nothing to her name. She doesn't even have a dime in her pocket okay, crazy. So seer was charged under section 238a of the criminal code, which, and I quote Not having any visible means of substance, is found wandering abroad or lodging in any barn or outhouse or any deserted or unoccupied building or any cart of wagon, or in any railway carriage or freight car or in any railway building, any railway carriage or freight car or any railway building, and not having a good account of himself or who, not having any visible means of maintaining himself, lives without employment.
13:15 They're really specific about locations. Yeah. I mean that's pretty wild that they would, I mean outhouse. I mean seriously, I mean I understand the time. So, all in all, she's a criminal Okay. She's a vagrant. So Lizzie Sears' arrest was rather commonplace, obviously unsavory, but it would have faded into obscurity, right Sure to obscurity right, sure. However, it became a catalyst for a major legal development, oh dear, which I will get into later I hope so, because now I'm intrigued you are on the edge of your seat. I mean just kidding, he's really not.
13:56 He's sitting far back into the couch with his legs up and beer in his pocket. Whatever you're in my pocket I was actually gonna sing your pocket the day after her arrest on may 18th 1917. Yeah, lizzie sear went to court what's her name? Sear, lizzie sear lizzie okay no jury of course. Why would they have one? vacancy wasn't considered serious enough for that, so she was left solely to the mercy of the magistrate. Ooh magistrates. With only her lawyer, John McKinley Cameron, to represent her. Okay. Okay. So John McKinley Cameron was quite the character. Yeah, he was a lawyer from Nova Scotia, oh, which is, you know, on the east coast of Canada?
14:43 Sure, okay, he started out representing mine workers. They moved out West to Calgary, alberta oh, do you know where Alberta is? Uh? Canada. Yes, I am not wrong. It's like the second to last on the Western Cause. What's? the furthest West one Cause. That's where Vancouver is right. Correct. Okay yeah, so it's British Columbia on the far west and then Alberta. You would think I'm 45 and I fucking don't know any of this. I know. I'm just as bad. I actually did a lot of research on the maps and stuff talking about this case. Because I knew where Vancouver was.
15:28 I knew that was British Columbia. Yeah, I know of Toronto, I don't know which, which territory. is that in? Is that Manitoba? I don't fucking know. Oh shit, no, we're just we're, we're buffoons? Yeah, we are, I mean. I mean we pretty much already called, called ourselves out, but Hold up, Cameron. He's now in Alberta, Calgary, yes, okay, which is like central Alberta, but like to the west, or, excuse me, to the south, central to the south. I have a question. Yes. Bradley with his hand up. Do you know the hockey team in Calgary's name? No. The Flames. All right Trivia. No the Flames. All right Trivia folks. There you go. Their logo is a C with some flames coming off the back.
16:10 Cool. Yeah, anyway, hockey eh. Cameron opened his own firm and criminal law was his focus. Okay. Okay. So he was brilliant. Everyone said so. He knew the criminal code inside and out. But he was also kind of unconventional. Sure. He would wear mismatched suits. I feel like they make movies about people like this. Probably, yeah, absolutely. Mismatched suits, sometimes even rubber boots, in court. What yes? He'd occasionally sleep in his garage loft with his hunting dogs Aw, that's cute. So a little quirky, a little quirky, a little eccentric, but he was serious about his work. He took on cases that other lawyers wouldn't touch, especially when the clients were super poor or fringes of society kind of thing Minors, immigrants, vagrants, so sex workers you know, a whole, but he had a real sense of justice.
17:03 So it seems. Well, that's a positive yeah, I'm gonna take a swig because you would. You would hope that he has, you know, kind of that demeanor to try and help these lowlifes. We'll just call them, for lack of a better term, yeah, um, or unfortunate people, whatever you want to say so. I mean down on their luck yeah, it's nice to have someone fighting for the little guy. Yeah, I sound like I'm a politician there. Yeah, absolutely, and the funny thing is, politicians never fight for the little guy anyways okay. So right from the get-go, cameron, the lawyer went on the attack yeah, of course you gotta fucking fight, fight, fight yeah, so he immediately declared, uh, the charge against sear as having no basis, pointing out that many women in Calgary didn't earn an income.
17:49 Right. But also weren't considered vagrants. Sure Okay, he entered a not guilty plea. He argued that the magistrate didn't have the legal authority to try the case because the magistrate was a woman. Well, shit. So, Ryan, why does that matter? Oh, I'll tell you. Okay, good. Uh-huh. So Ryan the John yeah, john Ryan, he gets up to testify first, testify brother yeah, and Cameron, just John Ryan, he gets up to testify first, testify brother yeah, and Cameron, just like nails him. So he's sharp, you know, but he also got this kind of like witty edge, so he basically uses Ryan's own words to make him look.
18:36 Like an idiot Less than virtuous. Sure, oh yeah, that too. Gonorrhea. Yeah, and it really made you wonder, like, how much ryan was actually like what he was saying was actually true, right. So now my favorite part of this whole thing oh, my word, you and I bradley, you and I, we're gonna role play. Oh, jesus, is this what you put on my computer. I put a file on his computer and we're gonna to read it together. This is his first time reading it. Oh, my word so if he flubs, that's only because he's sightseeing. Sightseeing, no sightreading, that's the word. He's sightreading. The worst part is I never learned how to read.
19:18 Is that all true? Everything but the reading part. Sorry, that's from a movie Name. That movie Give you $5. But the reading part sorry, that's from a movie name that movie give you five dollars, I don't know, cool I saved five dollars, folks. What was it from wayne's world? Oh, I've only seen that like once. It's not my fault open to your computer. Oh, I don't. I wasn't told that I should actually do it yes, we're gonna role play and you should have the document pulled up says Bradley, read the red portions. Yes, that's right, good job okay. So I am playing Cameron the lawyer, and you are playing Ryan the John. Okay. Let me get into character here. All right.
19:58 So when did you consult a doctor about your gonorrhea? I did not consult a doctor about it. When it started running, I went to the drugstore and bought some medicine. I'm sorry running it's got to be some kind of discharge. I'm just reading what's here in front of me. I know I'm putting in commentary, oh okay, okay, back to cameron because you made me feel stupid about that back to cameron. When was that? The day before yesterday what doctor did you see? I did not see any doctor. I went to mr mcgill and told him what. What was the matter? And he said I know the medicine you need.
20:41 Are you still running at large, Jesus Christ? What the running. I am not running at large. I have got a home and working every day. Got a family. No, I am not married. I rent a home and I stay at home every night. You are going to behave yourself and leave the girls alone until you are cured. Yes, I am okay. So here's the thing cameron was was driving it. Yeah, so he made it clear that what? Ryan wasn't exactly a model citizen when he came to public health. Right, he pointed out that ryan had contracted the disease before and, by his own admission, he was a regular client of sex workers. Right, so cameron's argument argument was that Ryan was just as likely, if not more, to spread the disease.
21:25 Sure, Makes sense. By sleeping with other women, he'd be the one creating a chain reaction, spreading it through the city. Right Spreading it. Wow, that's Spreading, yes, epidemic. Me as Cameron Outside of getting diseased, was there any other objection to her? the objection was I did not want to keep a prostitute in the house and she did not want to leave. I mean touche you took the prostitute to your house yes, for one night and after one dose of gonorrhea you thought you should not have a prostitute in your house. You are sure you are absolutely virtuous and could not have gotten it from any other woman.
22:08 So Cameron really dug into Ryan at this point. Okay, I don't mean to interrupt. I just read the next two and it's fucking fantastic. It's so basic but it's so great. Okay, so Ryan wasn't exactly known for his monogamy. Clearly. He admitted to seeing other sex workers. So Cameron basically asked how could he possibly pinpoint Lizzie? Ryan's answer was that she was the only one he'd been with recently. Cameron, with his like dry wit, just replied you are very moderate. What do you do for a living?
22:50 I work. That is so great. Are you working now? well, if I was not here, I would be working this afternoon at the Central Methodist Church. I mean, he's very straightforward. Yes, I think you will contaminate the church. Are you still going to work for the church? Yes. The adjudant oh yeah, there, Look at that I should read forward. The adjudant phoned me down at the Salvation Army. Did you reveal to him that you had gonorrhea? No, I did not. What work are you going down there? Because we do not want an epidemic to break out in the church.
23:33 Epidemic of gonorrhea. She is charged that on the 17th day of May she had no visible means of support. You don't know that. She is a decent married woman. I have seen her around. It takes two to have sexual intercourse. Are you a decent man? I guess I am working and earning my living. What the fuck. I don't know. I wish I was in this courtroom to see this, because I would just be laughing the whole fucking time. Seriously, I guess I am working and earning my living. Okay, so Cameron definitely got the better of Ryan and Cor, but Ryan wasn't naive, he knew the system.
24:15 Being a man with a steady job, working at a church, no less less, and a place to live, he had a clear advantage. It's why he probably felt safe reporting seer, even though he was basically admitting to his own involvement, sure, and he understood the public sphere of venereal disease and how prejudiced they were against certain groups. Yeah, it makes sense. So you see. Well, calgary had been pretty lax about vagrancy and prostitution in the past. Things had changed. By the 1910s there was a real push for moral reform driven by church groups, citizen organizations and women's groups, and they were putting pressure on the police to clean up the city. All right, and the police were responding. They got more organized under new chiefs and they were really cracking down, closing down all the brothels in the city.
25:02 Okay, so beyond just like moral outrage, there was a huge fear of venereal disease, sure, and even though it affected everyone, it was mostly blamed on quote-unquote, immoral women. Well, yeah, because they're the ones who got around to yes the or whatever. Blah, blah blah. Yes, historian David Bright points out that women were so worried about public health that they were willing to overlook individual rights. So, with that kind of atmosphere, plus the existing prejudice against Métis, which I will explain, and indigenous women. Lizzie Sear was really up against it from the start. Oh 100%.
25:42 Matisse refers to a distinct indigenous nation descended from unions between indigenous peoples and Europeans Okay, and is one of the three recognized indigenous peoples in Canada, along with First Nations and Inuit. Really. And we've talked about Inuit in the Whiskey War, origin of Weird Story. Sure have Mm-hmm Wow okay. So Ryan strategically painted Sear as a threat to public health, constantly mentioning her infection, sure, and he went so far as to say she shouldn't be running around carrying that disease doing this and that. He also added fuel to the fire by mentioning her separation from her husband Even more damaging insinuating an improper connection with a Chinese man.
26:31 Now he knew that, given the era's deep-seated prejudice, this would further discredit her right and I will say, the next role-playing section. Here chinaman is mentioned. However, they had a derogatory term and I'm not allowed, I'm not willing to say that. so you're allowed to say you just don't want. I don't want to say there's a difference so the derogatory word is now going to be called china man. Okay can I ask you it later? off off of sure sure but you are going to begin this section, sure am. Go ahead, ryan I knocked at the door and it was locked.
27:14 A few minutes after she opened the door and a china man was in the room with her. The China man was there for the laundry. The door was locked. Did you warn the Chinese man against her? No, when the Chinese man seen me, seen me, he walked out. You don't know if he took anything away with him or not. No, they were in the room together and the room was locked, wow. How do you know you have gonorrhea? Did you consult a doctor? It started running. What started running. My penis started running After a man gets one dose. He knows a little about it. I'm sorry, Hold on. I got to redo that one After a man gets one dose, he knows a little about it.
27:58 Sorry, I have to. I'm trying to get into character here. You did not consult a doctor. No, that's funny. So after Ryan, they called the arresting officer, William Simons, to the stand. Okay, Also thank you for the role playing. Yes, you're welcome. Thank you for the role playing. Yes, you're welcome. Thank you for uh. thank you for the interactive uh podcast so cameron started questioning him about the arrest and it turns out seer admitted to taking the ten dollars. Okay, but there was zero proof she'd given ryan the disease so there's also probably zero proof that she actually did anything with him.
28:39 I mean, there's literally no proof except for word of mouth from these two people Word of mouth. He said, she said yeah exactly Literally, he said, she said so Cameron was pretty direct, asking Simons you don't know anything about the facts, you don't know if she gave you him gonorrhea or anything. And Simons admitted no, just what he told me just a chinaman, wait what okay, but then out of nowhere, in the middle of the arresting officers questioning, I guess yeah, judge, or the magistrate, yes, alice jameson so she was still, and are you gonna get into why she shouldn't have been on this?
29:23 Yes, okay, cool. Out of nowhere. Magistrate Alice Jameson interrupts. Yes. Lizzie Sear, six months hard labor at McLeod. You can't just fucking do that. Cameron was stunned Well yeah, like, how does she, like she's hearing this testimony or whatever, and just says, no, fuck it Hard labor Six months. Sear didn't even have a chance to defend herself. Yeah, that's bullshit. And Cameron was furious. He said to the to the judge I shall see that your decision is overruled. Fucking A right Mm-hmm. I wish he had a gavel of his own.
30:03 So it's really shocking, especially considering Jameson was appointed specifically to give women a fair trial, and it seems like she completely missed the mark. Clearly, and according to historian John McLaren, female magistrates brought a unique viewpoint to the bench, quite different than males in the same position. The difference really showed in how they dealt with the vice, especially with women, who were seen as wayward, like sex workers. They were particularly outraged by how young women were being exploited and they felt that male officers, prosecutors and judges were often too lax, unfair and even insensitive in how they applied the law.
30:44 Oh dear. Now, just because they were women, it didn't mean that female magistrates were going to go easy on vagrant women. Well, of course not. Because, depending on their mindset and whatever they're going to be like, fuck this bitch. She's giving us a bad name, exactly. Exactly mindset and whatever they're going to be like. Fuck this bitch. Yeah, she's giving us a bad name, exactly exactly so. While they might have shown some leniency towards younger women or first-time offenders, they were pretty tough on anyone that was like unrepentant or hardened, so to speak. Sure, so figures like jameson and emily murphy, who was the other female magistrate at that time okay, so there's only two women magistrates at this time? Sure, they really believe that these women needed to be locked up for their own good, to reform them essentially.
31:25 Yeah, because that's always worked. Maybe Jameson looked at Sears' record and decided that she needed a wake-up call or something. Okay, but in the four years leading up to her arrest, sears had been arrested a few times, mostly for being drunk and once for vagrancy. Oh, so she was arrested once prior to this For vagrancy. Yes, Okay. So she's not a first-time offender. Right, right right. The longest she'd served was 60 days for that vagrancy charge. Oh wow. So when she came before Jameson again, she got the absolute maximum sentence allowed by law. Which is the six months, mm-hmm, okay. So she actually did kind of get off relatively lightly.
32:07 Jameson could have added like a hefty time or hefty fine on top of prison time, but she didn't Sure, and I will tell you like what Cyr did, okay. So Jameson was kind of in a tough spot. Cameron the lawyer, his challenge to her authority during sears trial was probably just one of many that jameson faced. Sure he'd questioned her qualifications just seven months later again, jesus. so it must have been incredibly stressful for jameson and she actually did speak about this in an interview with the Calgary Daily Herald in 1920. She said quote being the first woman magistrate was no position to excite envy, I assure you.
32:50 She admitted she had to deal with a lot of prejudice from lawyers and the police. She described feeling completely unwelcome when she first started and even thought about quitting. But then she said to herself, quote well, I'm here and I'm here to stay. Okay, all right. So it's possible Jameson was just trying to prove herself. It sounds like that's a very good possibility. Hard to say, for sure, but I mean that's not uncommon, I guess, for people to do that, yeah, so to do that. Yeah, so, but historian david bright points out that in 1917, being a prostitute or a vagrant wasn't really about proving specific crimes, right, it was more about proving someone's lifestyle okay so and that's what happened with seer sure.
33:33 so ryan, basically the, the john ryan basically painted a picture of her as someone who lived a certain way. He mentioned her infection, which was used to label her as being immoral. He said he'd seen her around saying that she was a known offender, and he highlighted that she was broke, had left her husband and associated with other considered undesirable. Do you think someone would really go around saying that, like saying those things? I mean, that just doesn't seem right. If there's something in it for him, I guess Well yeah, but I mean I don't know, I just find that weak.
34:16 Anyway, sorry, no, that's okay. So John McKinley Cameron was not one to take defeat lightly. No, I mean he wore rubber boots to court women, so bold, I mean in case it flooded. Exactly, he was going fishing afterwards. Maybe he's got to get them trout. Yeah, I heard they got some good fishing up in Canada. My dad went fishing in Canada. Yeah, yeah, yeah, he was supposed to take me. still waiting, dad, just kidding so cameron was actually known for his persistence and appearing before the alberta supreme court of appeal more than any other lawyer in a 20-year span. Wow, he's like.
34:58 Fine, I'll go to your boss I'll go to your boss, fuck you man so after losing kind of like I'm sorry yeah it's kind of like I'd like to speak to the manager. I always like to speak to your manager. So after losing lizzie sears case in jameson's court, he wasn't about to let it go he's like fuck this, whether it was simple stubbornness or something deeper. He decided to challenge not only the verdict, but also Jameson's right to be a magistrate. Okay, damn, going for the guns here, oh yeah. Because if she isn't allowed on the stand, then it's going to get overturned, essentially. And he would win that case with Sear. He's basically going through the back door.
35:39 Yeah, exactly yeah. Dirty. He, of course, went to. Justice David Scott of the Alberta Supreme Court. Okay, Scott dismissed his application even though he admitted he had his own doubts about women holding office. Wow, that wasn't misogynistic at all he basically said quote I have my reservations, but this isn't the right way to challenge it it's funny. It's funny that he he did not want. He clearly showed his hand that women are inferior. Yeah, and again we're talking about the 1912 yeah, 1917 to 1920. So I get it. I understand the time frame and the mindset back then, but it's like he didn't care for those people in those positions.
36:23 But he's like yeah, but you still can't do it this way, so it's really kind of funny. Yeah, I agree, but no. He's like yeah, but no, it's just funny because clearly again different times 100 years ago. Yeah. And you get these people that are like women should be in the home doing my laundry and making dinner and blah, blah, blah. Yeah. But there's obviously women in these certain high positions. But he's like no, we're still not going to go about it that way. Yeah, he agreed. By his statement. Yeah, he clearly is like I agree with you, but we just can't do it that way. So I mean, at least he had some morals, even though he's a fuck Undeterred, cameron took it to the appellate division of the Supreme Court of Alberta.
37:06 This time, justice Beck, stewart, cj Harvey and JJ Walsh also rejected his appeal. Oh okay, but Justice Stewart was very clear about his stance. He said, quote we should declare that in our province and in our time there is no legal reason to disqualify women from holding public office. And then he went on to say that they were returning to a more progressive view from the Middle Ages, rather than the more restrictive views that had become popular in the 19th century. So with that ruling, alberta made history. Oh shit, I always say Providence, providence to officially recognize women as legal persons with the right to hold public office.
38:02 So progressive. The Calgary Daily Herald even ran a headline that said judges find that Mrs Jamison is legally appointed. Oh, Jesus Christ. But the rest of Canada? Not so so much didn't see it that way tell us about it, I will sweet jameson continued her work as magistrate and she eventually retired comfortably in 1931. Wow cameron meanwhile kept up his successful career. Good, for him. He kept practicing law into the 1930s and passed away in 1943. Oh, and now, because Jameson's ability to judge was confirmed, they also validated Sears' sentence.
38:47 Of course Makes sense. So she served six months at the Northwest Mounted Police Barracks in Fort McLeod. There it is Sure. Which is about an hour and a half south of Calgary, right In pretty awful conditions it was crowded, poor ventilation. Well, you had said it's hard labor too. Oh, this is Right. Yes, but we don't know what that hard labor was, unfortunately. Yeah, I mean it could have been chopping down trees or hunting Sasquatch, we don't know. Or picking up a boulder walking 30 feet, putting down a boulder. Going back picking up a boulder walking 30 feet, putting down a boulder. The problem is when you say boulder every time.
39:27 I know you're not a big Indiana Jones fan or I haven't seen them that much, but I just think of the first movie and I'm just like the boulder rolling down. So so that reference was a movie with, um, robert redford. Okay, uh, the last castle, I think, is the name of the movie james gandolfini that's right. Yeah, one of his punishments as a prisoner was to pick up a massive boulder, walk 30 feet, put it down and go back and pick up another boulder, and it was massive and heavy I guess. I just think a boulder is being bigger than someone being able to pick up, so maybe a giant rock, but either way a very large rock. Yes, okay, so in 1920 1922 yeah, good year a lizzie sear.
40:10 We don't know if it's the lizzie sear, but a a Lizzie Sear was working. So there could be multiples. Lizzie Sear was working as a waitress at the King Edward hotel in Pinscher Creek near Fort McLeod. Okay, there were other people with the last name Sear there, so maybe she connected with family at that time. Sure. Possible. But after that, lizzie Sear kind of fades into historical records Obscurity, yeah, lizzie Sear kind of fades into historical records, obscurity, yeah. So it is pretty sad because it is pretty common that a lot of Matisse sex workers ended up that way. Sure, so remember I said that there was a major legal development earlier yes, you had mentioned that, yes and that the rest of Canada didn't recognize women as legal persons with the right to hold public office.
40:57 So with the whole not recognizing them to be legal persons? What exactly does that? mean oh, I will tell you oh thank goodness Because. But, yes. You have to wait. Oh fucking shit. For part two of this story, which will be next week. Hey, this is a two-parter. Hey, just so you know number two, you don't have to role play with me. Oh, thank God, Good Lord. So you get to wait to see what happens I'll be waiting with baited breath I was gonna say that, but I was trying to think of something more canadian.
41:43 I got nothing baited bruce, baited bruce what's it all about? Okay, this is our very first two-parter. How do you feel about that? I feel weird because we've talked about, because you don't know the ending of the story yeah, I feel like cliffhangers aren't my thang. Yeah, um, but we've talked about doing two-parters before and we just kind of squeeze it into a longer episode. We do, and we usually like to keep our episodes around a certain time frame, just, you know, because we don't want to lose Al's interest.
42:25 But yeah, no, it's weird because now I don't know and it's kind of infuriating. I want to know what's all about. This beer is really good though. Well, I will tell you, it does involve what is known as the Famous Five. Fox Force Five. Do you know what movie that's from? No, pulp Fiction, great movie. Don't remember that part. Pulp Fiction. Ah yes, great movie Don't remember that part? It's the pilot she did for the TV because John Travolta's character fuck, vincent Vega took Mia Wallace out.
43:09 Wow, you didn't just slam your beer down. And he wanted to know about she was an actress, but she only did a pilot. Oh, that's right. Yeah, yeah and the name of the show was fox force five okay, her character always told jokes and she told the one about the mom and tomato and dad tomato, whatever, and all that little tomato he was walking behind. Let's just catch up after she smushed him. Anyways, I know I didn't do it justice like a joke my mom would make. Yeah, maybe. Except for she spells ketchup like catsup, catsup Like C-A-T-S-U-P. I got that At least the last time I saw her write the word. Didn't you just show me a recipe that was with your?
43:51 mom oh, potentially, yeah, definitely. Yeah, my grandma's chinking gumbo sloppy joes. But it was your mom's handwriting, right, and she wrote cats up. Yeah, because I made a comment about that actually, because I just always think it's funny when people put cats up instead of ketchup. It's usually a geographic type thing, isn't? it Well. I mean, we both grew up in Nebraska and I spell it with a. K, so I don't know. It makes sense. Nebraska corn C catsup I get it. So am I saying it wrong then, or spelling it wrong? Apparently. I'm going to Google this Catsup. versus ketchup, Kate's mom. I'm joking about the C and the corn and the catsup.
44:32 I hope you understand. I'm always joking. Always, literally all the time. So I apologize. So catsup yeah, there is a reason for it right Is usually used in the South. Yeah, okay, yeah, interesting. And it originated from a Chinese fish sauce, really, which was brought to Europe and then westernized. I never heard that before that's interesting and then the heinz company did you know ketchup wasn't always green or it wasn't always red, it used to be green yes, I think I didn't know that yeah heinz company yeah, use ketchup. Yeah, but then later switched to ketchup to distinguish their product and then, and also, if I'm not mistaken, the the whole reason.
45:19 Like you never knew what was actually in it. It was literally just to mask the terrible taste of the meat and try and make it better, and then it actually started being made out of tomatoes and stuff and now it's a condiment that people love that it's probably I mean, I'm not saying I'm right here by any stretch but it's got to be one of the, if not the most used one of the most used condiments ever, yeah, ever. Because burgers, fries, hot dogs, whatever it might be, lots of different shit. Does your son Xavier like ketchup? Now? Because I know for a while he wasn't into condiments, so it's funny because literally last night he likes he's very picky, as you know.
46:00 Yeah. And he, there's these certain Lunchables. You've had a Lunchable before. For sure. So there's certain ones that comes with chicken nuggets yeah, and ketchup to dip them in yeah, he loves that. He likes the ketchup with it? Yeah, and ketchup to dip him in. He loves that. He likes the ketchup with it. Yeah, he dips his chicken nuggets into the ketchup and it's funny because these Lunchables, I mean they're cold, so they're cold chicken nuggets into cold ketchup. Which he doesn't really care. That doesn't bother him, he actually prefers colder food, I guess, to warmer food. I mean, when I make him a pizza, if I make him a frozen pizza at home, he'll uh he'll wait for it to cool down wait for it to be cold. Yeah, cool down, cold, whatever you want to say, but yeah, and in my kitchen this time of the year you've been there, it's chilly.
46:47 So, it cools down rather quick. Yeah, dinner. Last night I actually had vesper and him had those lunchables, so it's kind of funny. But the the problem is vesper, so it comes with four nuggets, ketchup to dip it in and two cookies I'm going for the cookies well, you need to talk to my daughter oh, we'll fight for each other. Fight for him. Okay, she'll get one and I get one. You'll have to fight her for that one, because she ate both of hers. And then Xavier usually doesn't like the cookies, which is kind of odd, and they're basically like generic Oreos, yeah. So I'm like can I have them? Sure, he gave them to me, I ate them.
47:29 And she finished I'm like you have to eat your chicken nugget first and she's like more cookie. I'm like you have to eat your chicken nugget first and she's like more cookie. I'm like you have to eat your chicken nugget. So she took a bite and then she ate her cookies. I'm like that's not enough. But then she starts searching for brothers. I'm like, oh shoot, maybe I shouldn't have ate those. So then I had a third one. He wanted more. I gave him the third one. I'm like can I give Vesper one of the cookies? He's like, yeah, so big brother came in the clutch there and helped his sister out. But it's super cute Anyways. How'd we go on the ketchup, ketchup talk. Ketchup, ketchup, wow. Doesn't matter. We really went on a tangent there. Yeah, we did Okay.
48:11 So how did you like your Mahorajah? Mahorajah, it's delicious. I finished two of them. I'm feeling it Kind of want a third. So, elle, again thank you for the suggestion on this. I know you work for them so you're a little biased, but I see why, because it was delicious and it also says Mighty Dank, smooth. They ain't joking. I liked my Limey's. I literally just opened up my second one while you were talking about your kids. Yeah, you did, but no, this was delicious. Awesome. I'm glad you like your Limey's Again. I know it's not Modelo, but it's a nice little alternative, it's an alternative.
48:52 Yeah, it's a nice little alternative, it's an alternative. Yeah, it's a great alternative For something a little different. Yeah, and. I really like the bright green can. I really really like the bright green can. I mean I'll have to have a Shandy, you'll have to have one of those one of these days. Yes, it's pretty good. So, yeah, I'll have to try one of yours as well next time you have them, because I mean, I used to sell a bunch of lineys. I like their products, I like what they are. um, I don't like that they're not brewed in Chippewa Falls anymore, but so it goes, uh, it's up towards, like the northwest side of Wisconsin, towards Minnesota, kind of uh was that? I always get my, my towns mixed up. Lac La Crosse, right, is that right, mm-mm?
49:36 I don't go that direction. Well, not many people do it's. I still find it funny because it's like flavor of the Northwoods. It's not the Northwoods, in my opinion. My parents are from the Northwoods. Yeah, yeah, they're from up north, that's like mid-north, okay, but either way, yeah, that's maybe me picking there, so but no, I, I like lineys, I like summer shandy. I wish they'd bring some of their old classics back, like big butt doppelbach. But either way, such a such a great logo just so you can say the name oh yeah, big butt, give me another big butt, sir. Doubleback, doublebock.
50:17 Doppelbock yes. Doppelbock. Yes, yeah, super fun German word Yep, cool For sure. Well, I suppose All right, buffoons. That's it for today's episode. Buckle up, because we've got another historical adventure waiting for you. Next time Feeling hungry for more buffoonery, or maybe you have a burning question or a wild historical theory for us to explore hit us up on social media. We're history buffoons podcast on youtube x, instagram and facebook. You can also email us at history buffoons podcast at gmailcom. We are bradley and kate. Music by cory acres follow us wherever you get your podcast and turn those notifications on to stay in the loop.
50:57 Until next time, stay curious and don't forget to rate and review us. Remember, the buffoonery never stops. Music by Corey Akers.
YouTube
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Podcast Addict
RSS Feed
Podchaser