If you like what you hear, help support our show!
Nov. 3, 2025

PerSwede Them: Black Sox Scandal

PerSwede Them: Black Sox Scandal
PerSwede Them: Black Sox Scandal
History Buffoons Podcast
PerSwede Them: Black Sox Scandal

A powerhouse roster, a miserly owner, and a storm of quiet resentment set the stage for baseball’s most infamous fall. We trace how the 1919 Chicago White Sox—frustrated by low pay and trapped by the reserve clause—slipped from favorites to fixers, and how a swarm of gamblers, middlemen, and one calculating kingpin turned the World Series into a high-stakes con. From the hit-by-pitch signal that opened Game 1 to the chilling threats before Game 8, every twist exposes what happens when money outruns ethics.

We walk through the backroom deals, the broken promises, and the odd moments that still stun: cash under a hotel pillow, missing confessions, a courtroom packed with boys in awe, and a jury that said “not guilty.” Then comes the true verdict that mattered. Newly empowered commissioner Kennesaw Mountain Landis banned eight players for life, drawing a bright line that rebuilt trust, centralized power, and created the modern model for sports integrity. The National Commission vanished, a single office took charge, and every ballpark posted clear rules to keep gambling out of the dugout.

And yes, we sit with Shoeless Joe Jackson. The pure swing, the .375 average, the letter he said he wrote, the $5,000 he took. Should greatness on the field outweigh failure off it? What about Buck Weaver’s silence? These stories aren’t just baseball lore; they’re case studies in governance, incentives, and how a league protects its soul when the odds turn crooked. If you love sports history, ethics in competition, or the origin story of the commissioner’s office, this deep dive is for you.

If this episode sparks you, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a review. Your take: should Shoeless Joe be in the Hall of Fame? We’re listening.

Send us a text

Support the show













This website contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and purchase a product, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the running of this website and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Please note that I only recommend products and services that I believe in and have personally used or researched.

00:00 - Opening Banter And Cider Pick

02:44 - Mad Libs Warm‑Up

07:20 - Setting The Stage: 1919 White Sox

12:45 - Low Pay, Reserve Clause, And Resentment

18:40 - Recruiting Gamblers And Pricing The Fix

24:20 - Rothstein’s Shadow And Missing Money

29:55 - Game One Signal And Early Losses

36:20 - Wavering Fix And Sox Fight Back

41:10 - Threats Before Game Eight And Collapse

46:05 - Rumors, Grand Jury, And Confessions

51:35 - The 1921 Trial And Acquittal

56:30 - Landis’ Lifetime Bans And Aftermath

01:02:20 - Shoeless Joe’s Legacy And Hall Debate

01:07:10 - Governance Reforms And Lasting Impact

01:11:30 - Mad Libs Recap And Closing CTA

0:15 Oh, hey there. Oh, hey there. I'm Kate. I'm Bradley. And this is the History Buffoons. Welcome. Yes, welcome. How are you doing? I am doing well. How are you today? I'm good. I'm good. Yeah. Today we are um recording on day seven. Nope. Game seven. Game seven of the World Series. We are, yes. So. Um, and I'm gonna go right into it because we have a long story today, and it is about a World Series. Oh, cool. Yes, nice, yes, I'm excited for that. I like baseball.

0:56 So, um, for those of you don't who don't know, we are Brewers fans, Milwaukee Brewers fans, and we got shut out by the Dodgers. And it's okay, they're a great team. Obviously, yeah, they have some great players. Um, but we we do want the Blue Jays to win only because the Dodgers won last year. Like, let's get give Toronto a trend a chance. And Toronto hasn't won in 32 years, uh the World Series Championship. So that's the only reason why I'm voting for them. But Dodgers are a great team. Bonnie, do you want to get out? Oh. Bye, Bon. Bye, Bonnie. They always sneak in, don't they?

1:36 They sure do. Okay, so like I said, this is gonna be a longer one, but we're gonna play a game at the beginning and a game at the end. Oh, jeez. All right, so real quick, we're gonna have a beer. Uh, we're starting off with a cider. It's Mackenzie's black cherry flavored hard cider. Um, it's very delicious. We've actually tried some. Yeah, I've had this and um we wanted to rave about it on the podcast because it's delicious. We don't go out of our way for ciders a lot. No. But um and I don't drink them hardly at all. Right, but once in a great while, and this one's delicious. Like it's quite a bit different from the basil mint, so oh, I love the basil mint though.

2:19 But yeah, the Mackenzie's Heart Cider Black Cherry. Cheers. Um, it's an it's called an American tradition. Yeah. Where is this? Did we from Utica, New York? Oh, okay. I didn't know. Okay. They also had a blueberry one, but we were like, mm-hmm. We don't like blueberry. I don't like blueberry. Um, but it's so good. It is. So, anyways, all right, let's get into it. Okay, so you remember Mad Libs? Oh, yeah. Yeah, that's what we're gonna do. Oh, Jesus. Now I gotta remember my pro like pronouns and adjectives. That's cracked. Oh boy. I haven't been in school in a long time.

3:00 Okay, so the first one. I need an adjective. Uh funny. Um, number two, I need a famous athlete. Uh Herschel Locker. Who's that? Football player. He's a really good running back. Running back, what does he play currently? Or is he a an older He's older. He's been out of the league for quite some time. Okay. What did he play? Or what team? Oh boy, was he on Dallas? Is that right? No, I'm second guessing myself. I'm drawing a blank. Past tense verb.

3:42 You're already then. Plural noun. Lemons. Wait, is that right? Okay. A silly nickname. Squiggly face. An ING verb. Um bending. Adjective. Courageous. Amount of money. Oh, not like uh amount of money.

4:23 It's amount of money. Amount of money. It's not like amount of money. Amount of money. Um three hundred and sixty two dollars and seventy-two cents. Three hundred and sixty-two dollars and what? Seventy-two cents. Seventy-two cents. Okay. Illegal activity. Drug dealing. Exclamation. Wow. Wow. A drink. Mackenzie's black cherry hard cider. That's fitting. Black cherry hard cider.

5:07 Yes. Um, a weapon. Uh battle axe. A made-up statistic. Oh, a made-up statistic. Um put me on the spot here. Yeah, that one's a trickier one. That one's very tricky, so um. I don't know. Um fuck, keep stalling here. Trying to think. How many pounds per an inch can you run? I don't know. Okay.

5:47 Hold on. I don't know what that would be. Made up statistic. Because everything's a statistic these days. Yeah, I'm I'll try to like finagle that one. Okay. Okay. Um, silly nickname. Uh slob face. With a P or B. Slob. And a judgy phrase. Judgy phrase? Oh boy, I don't really judge people, so this one's hard for me. What does that mean?

6:29 Is it more like a condescending thing towards somebody? You could be, yeah. Um judgy phrase. Oh, I've got one. Oh, then you do it. It could be um you should start doing that, people like it better. Yes. I like that. That may have been something I've said in this lifetime. It was all in chest, but this works for this. So as far as pounds per inch, say a number. Twelve. Okay.

7:10 Okay. I think that'll work. Okay. I have no idea what that means either. I just came up with something. Okay, so that will be at the very end. Oh, okay. Okay, so we're gonna talk about the black socks gambling scandal. Oh, wasn't that in like 1906? Higher. 11? Higher. 15. A little bit higher. 17. 19. Damn. 1919. I thought it wasn't that's right. I knew that with um shoeless Joe Jackson. Mm-hmm. Fuck yeah, let's do it. Okay, so the Chicago White Sox of 1919 were a powerhouse.

7:51 The Black Sox? They're the White Sox. I know. So they had recently won the 1917 World Series and had stars basically at at every position. Yeah. So this is where you can open up the picture that I gave you. It's just a reference for all the people that we're gonna be talking about today. And where is that? Oh, untitled. Which one is it? So it's under untitled folder. And then it just oh, there it is now. That was weird. I like how the name of the name of it is called Igor Diotlove.

8:33 Why is it called that? Anywho, okay. Okay, so basically, I'll put up a picture here. Um, but it's basically just a ball field with all the names and their positions. Did they not have a catcher? So these are just the players that I'm gonna be talking about. Oh, I see. Okay. Okay, so in left field was shoeless Joe Jackson, a South Carolina batting prodigy. Um, he was illiterate, but he could pretty much hit anything thrown at him. His career average batting average was a 0.356. Wow. Yeah. So when you say averages, you can just say 356. Yeah, you don't have to put the point in there because it is obviously uh of one, technically.

9:18 Okay, but yeah, it's just he's he had a 365 bet. 365? Yeah, okay. 356. Sorry. Sorry, I don't know if no, I I think I switched it. I was a little dyslexic there. So at third was Buck Weaver. Buck Weaver, okay. The infield featured Chick Gandal at first and Swede Risberg at short. Okay. And on the mound, they had Eddie um Sicot. I should have looked that up. Sickot. Um, he was nicknamed Knuckles for Knuckles. Yeah. And then we had Claude Lefty Williams. He was the other pitcher that we're gonna talk about. Right hander. Um, he must have been.

9:59 If they called him Lefty. Yeah, exactly. Um sorry, I didn't mean to derail you there. Jeez, and then they had um Oscar Happy Felsh. Felsh, yeah, in center. Felsch, yeah. And then by all accounts, the team was pretty dominant. Um, but there was a cautionary tale about uh uh amongst them. Yeah. Yeah. Charles Kamisky. That's what the ballparker is named after. Really? Yeah, Kaminski. Apparently he was a dick. Well, he's from Chicago. Comisky was the White Sox owner, and he was known as the old Roman Roman, and he was a legendary cheapskate.

10:47 Oh, okay. He had been a star player in the 1880s himself, but as a player, he was quite stingy. Oh, really? Yeah. Ask me what base he played. What position he played? What position did he play? Because I looked it up because I thought you would ask me. First base, thank you. Thank you, thank you. You're welcome. So the players' salaries at this time was low, even for the times. Sure. Yeah. So the Sox might have been the highest paying team in 1919 on paper, but many felt Kamiski was pretty miserly and paid his talented men no more than the worst players. Oh. If that makes sense.

11:28 Everyone got paid the same for the most part. Pretty much, yeah. Um, no perks. He gave the team a bonus for winning the 1917 pennant, which turned out to be nothing more than um flat flat champagne. How did how did he make it flat? He probably shook it up like an like an asshole. I don't know. Like an asshole. He even promised pitcher Eddie Sikat a$10,000 bonus if he won 30 games and then promptly benched him after his 29th win to ensure he'd never collect. What a dick. I told you. Wow. Yeah that's a dick fucking move. Komisky's penny pension was so bad, rumor has it, he refused to pay for laundry.

12:14 So he made players wash their own uniforms and they chose not to. So after each game, the white socks uniforms got filthier and filthier out of protest. Right. And it kind of turned turned the uh the team's white jerseys into black jerseys. They have, I like their old black jerseys. Yeah. They actually have black jerseys, they're they're always really sharp to me. So beyond being underpaid, the Sox players were trapped by baseball's strict reserve clause. Okay. Um, which bound them to their team with no free agency. So even after your contract ends, you're stuck there, you're still stuck there.

12:58 So I'm not really understanding. There's no union, there's no leverage. Interesting. Yeah, and all the players were really frustrated with this. I would imagine so because they're literally stuck in this shitty situation. Yeah. I never heard of that before. So interesting. By late 1919, with the Sox headed to the World Series, the this perfect storm was brewing. Okay. Some players saw a golden opportunity to stick it to Kamiski and make a buck on the side. Ah, so that's what it all kind of stemmed from. Gotcha. So the eight players that I listed, yeah, the ones that you see on this um the picture picture. Yep. Yep, yep. Were implicated in this plot. They were called the eight man out.

13:39 Eight men out, yeah. That's a movie. Oh, is it? Yeah, I'm pretty sure. And then Ray Leota played Shulas Joe Jackson and Field the Dreams. So Chick Gandal, the first baseman, yeah, he was the alleged mastermind. Oh. A third he was 31. He was kind of a rough and tumble first baseman type. Gandal was the ringleader who first conspired with gamblers. Okay. So he was tired of Kamiski's tight fit tight fist, and Gandal saw nothing wrong with earning a little bonus on the side. So he pulled some strings. Oh dear. Now, Knuckles, Mr. Eddie Sickot.

14:19 I'm so sorry if I butchered that. Oh, I'm I'm he was the pitcher at he was 35 and was one of the game's best players, essentially. Okay. And he was the presumed game one starter. Sure. Okay. He also had that personal grudge with the being benched on game number 29 out of 30. What a dick. Yeah. Yeah. So Sickot agreed to participate if he got$10,000 up front. Oh. Yeah. And Gandal knew that Eddie if knew getting Eddie on board was pretty crucial. Sure.

14:59 And they needed him to be part of the fix. Okay. Well, yeah, especially if he's pitching. Yeah. So then we had Claude Lefty Williams, the other pitcher. Yeah. He was 26 left-hander with 23 wins that year. Um, he was a lot more soft-spoken, but still under Gandal's sway. Sure. And Lefty went along with this scheme. Right. His motivation was pretty much like everybody else, just kind of greed and and grievance kind of a thing. Right. That's funny. I mean, it's funny how the owner basically fucked all these people into doing this.

15:40 It drove them to do this. Obviously, it still wasn't right what they did. No. But um, it's crazy that because of him just being a stingy owner and fucking that one guy out of 10 grand bonus and whatever, not even washing their fucking clothes. I mean, come on, what the hell? Yeah. So then we have George Buckweaver, the third baseman. He was actually kind of a clean-ish conspirator. Okay. Um, Buck was a fiery, talented third baseman who attended the fix meetings, but insists that he never agreed to throw the games or accept money. He was just kind of a stand-in almost. He was like a fly on the wall. That seems weird. But a known fly. Yeah. See, that's the thing.

16:20 It's like, why are you going then if you're not going with it? Yeah. That seems odd. Um, Weaver actually ended up playing really hard in the World Series. Um, he battled a 324 with no errors. He batted. Yeah, that's what I said. I said battled. Of course I did. Sorry. That makes me cough sometimes. So he is in this like eight man out um he's part of the group fiasco because he didn't report it. He was in the meetings, but he he didn't collect money, but he didn't report it. Yeah. Yeah. He's guilty of being in the wrong room, but not actually cheating, if that makes sense.

17:03 Oh, yeah, I get it. Okay. Shoe this Joe Jackson, the left fielder. Well, I think he's the most famous of the bunch. Yeah, he was the biggest um name and a fan favorite. Yep. He was illiterate and naive. Um, he did he was not at the initial meetings. Okay. Um, he said that he was never invited, but we all I already told you that Gandal wanted him to be a part of this. Right. Obviously, like he's he's gonna help them throw the game. Well, yeah, because he's one of the best players. And if they if if he's hidden away to win his normal thing, he's gonna be like, wait a minute, we're supposed to lose, dude. Right, exactly. So they needed their star, essentially.

17:44 Yeah. Um, Jackson later testified that Gandal offered him ten thousand dollars and he refused twice, and that Gandal basically told him the fix is in with or without you. Oh, so Joe ended up with five thousand dollars in dirty money, which he claimed um was shoved at him by teammates, like, here, fucking take it. And he's like, I don't want to, I don't want fine. Jesus. Um, in the series, Jackson actually played extremely well. He hit the only home run of the series and batted a 375. Wow, that's pretty good. Yeah. Then we have Oscar Happy Felsh from center field. Okay. He was power, he was a power hitter. Um, he wasn't obviously happy about his salary either, and he got roped into the fix of of you know the promise of a payday.

18:31 Even though he his name, nickname was happy, he wasn't happy. It's weird. He was a 300 hitter with a big ego. Okay. Later admitting, quote, I got lucky and caught on as a big leaguer, but I wasn't making big league money. Gotcha. So in the series, felshi's plays, raised some eyebrows, he missed some catchable balls. People wondered if Happy was deliberately playing sad. Playing sad. Okay. Now we've got Fred McMillan. Okay. He was a utility field infielder. Um, he was kind of like an accidental conspirator. Oh, okay. Yeah. He hardly ever played, uh, but he happened to overhear that a fix was happening.

19:18 So Fred's reaction was essentially cut me in or I'll rat you out. Oh. Yeah. Because he wasn't getting playing time anyway. So because he probably was not as good as the other guys. Okay. Interesting. So the others agreed to um to include him. Um, and his role in the games were was really minimal, and he got supposedly was gonna get an equal slice of the payoff. Jeez. And then we have the shortstop, Charles Swede Risberg. Okay. Um, Swede was a big, strong shortstop. He was known to be a bit of a bully. Um, he was kind of Gandalf's muscle, essentially, in the clubhouse and like during the fix meetings.

20:00 Sure. If any teammate wavered on the fix, Suede would sorry, Swede would persuade them. Oh yeah, geez, he'd persuade them. He'd persuade them. Yo, that's so cute. I mean, right? That's so cute. I'm gonna write that down. Oh, thanks. Okay, so though oh, he hit a measly at 83. Oh god. Yeah, so he got like a hit. Yeah, basically. Yeah. Jesus. Yeah.

20:40 So with this motley crew of frustrated talent, if I do say so myself, yeah, the stage was set. All they needed was some gamblers. Okay. Okay. September of 1919, as the world saw world, as the White Sox um headed towards the pennant, Chick Gandal quietly began shopping, shopping for this dangerous idea of throwing the World Series for money. Yeah. And on September 18th in Boston, during a road trip, Gandal met with a known Boston bookie, Joseph Sport Sullivan, in a hotel. Mm-hmm. Okay. Over drinks and cigars.

21:20 Yeah. Chick let Sullivan in on his plan. He and some of his teammates were willing to lose on purpose. He said, quote, I think we can put it in the bag. Yeah. Okay. The price tag discussed was$80,000 to tank the series. Gandal later upped it to an even$100,000. Okay. Approximately$1.8 million today. God, that's so little. It doesn't seem like much. So obviously, this is over a hundred years ago, so money's a lot different. But even for today, you said 1.8?

22:00 That is nothing. Divided by$8. Eight people? I mean, that is nothing. Yeah. Especially when you know like people like uh, what's his name? The guy on the Mets. Soto, I think. No, is that right? I could be wrong. Doesn't matter. One guy on the Mets just signed for like$765 million or whatever. Something insane like that. Or Shoei Otani on the Dodgers is getting like I think his is well over 600 million or something, too. I don't remember exactly what it was. Or fucking Mike Trout signed a few this is a few years back for 450 million dollars. One fucking person, and they're supposed to split$100,000, 1.8 today.

22:43 That is nothing. Holy shit. Yeah. But I mean, that's this is the during the era even when like football players used to play football. I know we're talking about baseball, but like similar thing. They would play football in the fall and then they would go sit to their regular job the rest of the year kind of thing. Cause they just didn't make any money doing it. Yeah. But now they make all sports figures basketball, football, baseball, even hockey. I mean, hockey's probably they're probably more underpaid than most of the other sports, from what I understand, but they probably still make pretty good fucking money. Yeah. So it's just wild that they wanted to do this for ten thousand dollars each.

23:26 That's fucking insane. Yeah. So Sullivan was no stranger to fixing outcomes. He was very interested, but yet he didn't have that kind of money on hand. So he'd need backers. Sure. So a few days later, back in Chicago and then in New York, they're going all over the place trying to find these men. Right. The players held secret meetings to firm up who was in. So on September 21st, in Gandal's room at a hotel in New York City, several White Sox players gathered to hear the proposal. Okay. Accounts varied exactly on who attended, but the key figures like Sicott, Williams, Felsch, and Risberg were there. Um, so was Buck Weaver, who maintains he only sat and listened, but you're still part of it, yeah.

24:12 You're still going. Yeah. So it was at this meeting that Eddie Sicott demanded his$10,000 up front. Right. Okay. So that was basically$187,000 today. Jesus Christ. Basically a signing bonus for going crooked. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. If the money wasn't going to be produced, he was going to back out. So this prompted one of the group's smarter ideas, relatively speaking, getting the money in advance. Yep. Then potentially double crossing the gamblers by not following through and still winning. Oh dear. Yes. They should have done that. Third baseman Buck Weaver supposedly suggested this double cross plan, take the cash and then win the series.

24:53 As Gandal put it later, quote, we agreed this was a hell of a brainy plan. Okay. All old timey talk. We're gonna con the con men. Con the con man. Uh what a brainy plan. So at this point, the ball player scheme turned into a circus of competing gamblers because world word spread. See, don't you think that would I mean I know they're in like a seedy fucking environment with the gamblers and stuff, but don't you feel like, hey man, word could get out on this? So what if one of them talked?

25:34 So wow. Yep. So Gandalhead started with Sport Sullivan, um, but word got around. Yeah. Um, and it was like shark smelling blood in the water. Like every big time better wanted a piece of this action. Right. Soon there were multiple groups of gamblers trying to get in on the fix, sometimes unbeknownst to each other. Oh, sure. Yeah. So one of those eager betters was ex-pitcher Sleepy Bill Burns. Sleepy. Mm-hmm. And his pal Billy Maharg. Maharg? Apparently it's Graham spelled backwards. Oh, that's weird. He needed an alias, and Graham didn't sound good enough.

26:16 Maharg. Maharg. Doesn't it sound like we're like the seven dwarfs up in here? We got lefty, happy, and we've got maharg. Mahar sleepy and yeah, yeah. Shoeless. So hearing the rumors of the fix, Burns and Maharg um approached Sicat with an offer to top Sol Sullivan's price. Okay. And that's when they dangled the$100,000 to throw the series. Gotcha. So Gandal and the pre um the players actually agreed to this richer deal at first. Um, but Burns and Maharg didn't actually have the thousand thousand dollars either. Of course. They were middlemen.

26:56 Yeah. So they decided to recruit the biggest fish in their pond, Arnold Rothstein. Oh, good old Rothstein. So Arnold, the big bankroll, Rothstein was a notorious New York gambling kingpin. Yeah. Okay. Um, he was actually a character in The Great Gatsby. Right. Yeah. Um Rothstein was wealthy, he was smart, he was ruthlessly fond of betting. Sure. Um, he said he would bet on anything he could fix. Well, right, because he can force the outcome. Yeah, and he could finance the hundred thousand dollar bribe.

27:38 Sure. Yeah. But initially, Rothstein was quite skeptical. When Burns and Mahark tracked him down at a at racetrack with their proposal, Rothstein basically blew them off. Oh, thinking this uh scheme was too risky and complicated, so many players involved, that kind of a thing. Too many chances of it going bad. Yeah. Yeah. According to one account, Rothstein equipped a rather off-color analogy to express his doubts, saying, quote, if nine guys go to a bed with a girl, she'll have a tough time proving the tenth is the father. Well said. Yep. So too many cooks in the kitchen. Yeah.

28:19 Basically, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's funny. Behind the scenes, though, Rothstein was maneuvering. He was he was gathering. Sure. Yeah. Some historians believe that he quietly decided to bankroll part of the operation. After all, once he could do it at arm's length, so he kind of just took over quietly, went behind the scenes and did it. Yeah. So sport Sullivan also went to Rothstein for help. And this time Rothstein bit, which he was already in on it. But he's like, sure. Okay. Um, he sent an associate, Nat Evans, to meet with the players in Chicago and assure them that the money was coming. Right.

28:59 So Rothstein agreed to fund$40,000 up front, which was half. Yeah. Um, with another$40,000 to be held until the end of the series. Which makes sense. Oh, for sure. 50%, yeah. Well, and like they said, they wanted to possibly double cross them and they need that money up front. And then obviously, yeah. So, no, I get that. Sullivan, entrusted with the first 40k, promptly gambled almost all of it on the Reds to win, which is who they were playing, the World Series. Oh, okay. Okay. Instead of paying the players. All right. Sullivan figured the players would get their money after they lost, and he might as well make the betting profit in the meantime.

29:46 So the double crossers were double crossing. So much double crossing. Does that mean we're straight and narrow now? I don't think so. Okay. In the end, just before. Game one of the World Series, only$10,000 in cash actually reached the players. Oh, wow. Okay. On the night of September 30th, Eddie Sickot found$10,000 under his pillow in the team hotel. Basically, his upfront front fee. Yeah. It's like a fucking tooth ferry. That's one hell of a tooth fairy. No kidding. I only got like change. Um, Sickott promptly sewed the money into the lining of his jacket for safekeeping.

30:27 That's fucking wild. The rest of the team, zero. They got zero money up front. But he was adamant that he needed his money up front, otherwise, he's gonna back out and or pay possibly say hey. Right. So they wanted to keep him happy, I guess we'll call it. Yeah. So the fix was now in motion. They expected to get paid in installments as they intentionally lost games. Okay. So roughly$20,000 after each defeat in the best of nine series. Isn't it weird weird that it used to be best of nine? That's a lot. Yeah, that's a lot of games. If they lost five games and they're by the series, the total would add up to the agreed upon$100,000. Okay. Yeah.

31:08 So October 1st, 1919, game one of the World Series, Chicago White Sox versus the Cincinnati Reds in Cincinnati. Yeah. Um, whispers of the fix had started started circulating among the gambler community, which everybody knew. Yeah, that's why like they went to too many fucking people. Yeah. And then too many people talked because shit's gonna get out. And then it caused betting odds to shift dramatically in favor of the the Reds. Right. So a few sports writers had started hearing these rumors too. Right. Um, writer Hugh Fullerton and ex-pitcher Christine Matthewson, um, they agreed to keep out keep an eye out on the field of anything fishy.

31:50 Interesting. Yeah. Still, most of the fans were oblivious and they were there to see the good show. You know, good wild, yeah. So the game began. Eddie Sicott's first batter faced. Reds leadoff man, Maury Wrath, was hit by a pitch square in the back. Oh. And that was just the second pitch of the game. So, like one pitch and then second pitch got hit in the back. Wow. This was a pre-arranged sign to the gamblers. That they were gonna do it. We're gonna go through with it. Gotcha. That was the sign. I'm gonna hit this this batter. Oh, wow. I mean, that's a good because it can't that can obviously happen, but yeah. Wow. Yeah. All right. So when this fixed signal, the game unraveled from there for the socks.

32:34 Yeah, Sicat, normally a controlled pitcher, suddenly looked inexperienced. He gave up hit after hip and made uncharacteristic mistakes. Sure. Okay. In one instance, he bumbled a routine grounder and threw wildly to second base, flubbing a double play and drawing suspicious glances from the press box. Oh dear. Of course, the Cincinnati Reds were like, This is great. Look at us go. We're winning. The Reds won nine to one. Jesus. Sicat got knocked out by the fourth inning after giving up his barrage of hits and runs. Sure. Quote, he looked like hot garbage out there. How does hot garbage look? Probably like Sicat.

33:14 I see what you did there. Meanwhile, some White Sox players were too bad to ignore. Right. Like they were, you're too obvious. Right. Shortstop Swede Riseberg fielded a grounder casually and made an unhurried throw to first, missing a sure double play. Right. Buck Weaver. Okay. Um, he he uncorked. I don't know why I wrote that. Um, he had a wild throw after fielding a bunt, causing a collision that knocked the ball loose. Okay. So it ultimately looked like the three stooches out there on the field.

33:55 Like when we see the cubs do that. Oh my gosh. When there's three going after the same ball, I always say, run into each other. Run into each other, run into each other. Cubs have done that for us. I know. Because I hate the cubs. They suck. So the next game, uh, game two on the mound was Claude Lefty Williams. Okay, so that's the other one. Yep. Claude, um, perhaps nervous, watched, walked a bunch of Reds. Um, they lost four to two, but that's what he was supposed to do. So don't you think like they were just gonna plan on losing five straight? Wouldn't it make sense to throw a win in there? Yes, it does. Because that would kind of pull suspicion, like, oh, maybe they are trying, they're just not playing well right now or something.

34:41 Yeah. Because I feel like, especially in nine-game series, you have to lose five. It's a lot of games in a row to lose. Yeah. They do win. They do, okay. They do win one, at least. Okay, gotcha. So while not as blatant of a score as the game one, um, Chicago's play was still really lackluster. And after two games, the heavily favored White Sox were down 0-2 in the series. Right. So, more alarmingly, for our eight conspirators, they had not been paid as promised. Right. After game one's loss, the players expected the$20,000 payout. They got the money's tied up in bets right now, kind of a thing.

35:24 After game two, Gandal angrily confronted the gambling goat, the middleman, demanding$40,000 owed for the two losses. Right. And the bag men actually scounged together about$10,000 more, bringing the measly total to$20,000. Jesus Christ. The pillow cash. Yeah, yeah. Wow. Yeah. That's fucking amazing that they're like, they plan this whole thing and they're getting literally fucked. And they get even more fucked afterwards. So that was half of what they should have had by now. The Sox players realized that they were being strung along, betrayed by the betrayers. Yeah.

36:04 And at this point, several of them got cold feet about continuing the fix. So they're like, maybe we should start playing it. Yeah, they're like, to heck with throwing games if we're not getting paid. Well, right. The whole point of doing what they're doing is to get paid. So okay. So the conspirators begin whispering about switching back to honest baseball and trying to win the series back. Okay. And so in game three, with a rookie pitcher named Dickie Kerr, who was on the bound but not in the fix. Right. Um, the White Sox actually tried. Oh. Um, Chicago won three to zero. Okay. Now the gamblers were like, oh shit. So did they get them their money? Well, to keep the fix going before game four, the gamblers finally coughed up, coughed up another 20,000.

36:48 So this is a total of 40,000 they gave him. Yes, yes. Okay. And he promised another 20k after game four if the Sox lost it. Okay. Okay. So Gandal took the 20,000 and split it four ways around$5,000 each among Riseberg, Felsh, Williams, and Jackson. Okay. Gandal cut out McMullen and Weaver from the split. They would actually never see a dime. Why did he do that? Fred McMullen wasn't originally part of the plan. He eavesdropped on a meeting and basically said, Cut me in or I'll spill the beans. Right. Um, Buck Weaver attended the fixed meeting, but refused to say he was, yeah.

37:29 Yeah, he refused to participate and never accepted any money. So Gandal saw him as like not part of it. Part of it. Yeah. Yeah. Makes sense. So the fix resumed. Game four. Oh, also, that wasn't part of my research before, but you're welcome. And put it in there just for you because I knew you would ask that channel. Wow. That was part of my research. Let's keep that going. Let's move on. Jesus. Game four went to Cincinnati two to zero. Was a cotton back on the mound doing his best worst ever. His best worst. His best worst.

38:11 Eddie Eddie pitched well for a few innings and then imploded in one inning. On purpose. He made two errors in the fifth inning alone. Okay. Um a bad look for a veteran. Right. Game five the next day saw Lefty Williams lose again, five to zero, barely putting up a fight. And at that point, the Reds led the series series uh four games to one. Yeah. So the White Sox had effectively secured Cincinnati's championship. Pretty much. So the double crossing and mutual distrust hit a climax after game five. Okay. The gamblers again failed to deliver the promised additional money to the players for the latest losses.

38:53 Oh dear. The total paid out was still far below what was owed. Right. Agreed upon, yeah. Yes. Okay. So in the players' eyes, the deal's off. They've been lied to. They just decided to stop tanking and play to win the rest of the way. Oh wow. In game six, the Sox came out swinging, winning five to four in extra innings. Oh wow. They followed that in game seven with another legit victory, four to one. So right now it's four to three in the series. Okay. Yes. So the series stood red's four, uh, socks three. Yeah, through seven games. Yeah. So like the impossible is starting to seem like it could be possible.

39:34 Like these little measly black socks coming up here when in the series. White Sox? Yes, the White Sox. They call it the Black Sox. They weren't they used to be the Black Sox? No. So they called it the Black Sox one because of their filthy ass uniforms, but also because of the gambling scandal. I see. Okay. Okay. The gamblers who had bet big on Cincinnati were now sweating bullets. So Arnold Rothstein um was not the type to leave things to chance. Right. So with potentially huge winnings and his reputation at stake, he um took decisive action to ensure that the Socks didn't complete their double cross. Okay. So prior to game eight, a gangster associate of Rothstein paid a threatening visit to pitcher Lefty Williams.

40:21 The message was really clear. I'm sure it was. Lose game eight in the first inning, or you and possibly your family will face dire consequences. Oh dear. But again, pay them their money then. So I mean, this is why doing shit like this is not a good idea. It's not a good look on you. October 9th, 1919, game eight commenced. Yep. Terrified Lefty Williams took the mound for Chicago and promptly did exactly what the gangsters wanted. Sure. He gave up four straight hits and three runs all in the very first inning. Wow.

41:01 Yeah. Um, this was um also the time when they yanked him out, and they're like, okay, you're done after the first inning. You're done. We can't have you no more. Yeah. Okay. So with Chicago's morale broken and pitching stuff, then the Reds went on to beat the White Sox 10-5, clinching the World Series five games to three. Wow. So the Reds became the champions, though their victory was completely overshadowed by whispers that it was handed to them. Sure. So one little footnote in that final game eight, shoeless Joe Jacks Jackson hit the only home run of the entire series. Wow, that's wild. Yeah. Um, even in defeat, and though technically part of the fix, Joe Jackson was like, I can't not do something.

41:46 Right. I can't help a little bit, you know. Oh, for sure. So he and Buck Weaver also ended the series as statistical stars for Chicago, leading the team and hitting and fielding perfectly. Oh wow. Yeah. And that's really sad because this tainted their careers so bad. I mean, Shula Joe Jackson was like a promising baseball player. Anyways, we'll get to that. So these facts would later become key arguments for who believed Jackson and Weaver were too good to be guilty. Right. Because they did well. Yeah. But in October 1919, um, the the the fix wasn't quite public yet. Right. All anyone knew was that the Mighty White Sox had inexplicitly fallen to the Reds.

42:31 Sure. Um, some called it the biggest upset in baseball history. Others started calling them the Black Sox. Interesting. Yeah. So after this series ended, rumors of the fix um in the background started kind of boiling over. Right. Um, the the journalist that I had mentioned before, Hugh Fullerton, wrote that the suspected that they suspected this series had been played for gamblers rather than for glory. Fullerton even published a an article in December 1919 openly asking if baseball was crooked. Oh, geez. Not just the team. So he thought everyone kind of was in on it, kind of scenario. Wow. All right. So the very idea that beloved baseball heroes would deliberately betray the game was really hard for people to swallow.

43:17 Sure. I mean, it's America's pastime. Yeah, and the baseball establishment certainly didn't want to believe it either. No, of course not. So White Sox owner Charles Comiskey, despite privately having suspicions, publicly denied any wrongdoing and even offered a reward for potential information. Sure. Comiskey announced a$10,000 reward for anyone who could provide provide proof of a fix. Well, we knew he had it because he didn't give it to that one guy for 30 games. So it was likely meant to reassure fans that he did want the truth. Um, no one took him up on that reward. Right. Um, because the gamblers were the ones with the proof.

43:58 Right. Yeah. Of course. Yeah. So behind the scenes, Kamiski took more cut covert action. Okay. He hired private detectives to snoop on his own players during the winter and the 1920 season. Oh, wow. So they these detectives did not find definitive evidence. Um, the fix had been pretty poorly kept as a secret, but actual proof was minimal. Sure. So with nothing concrete, Kamiski chose to keep his team intact in 1920. Okay. Surprisingly, he renewed the contracts of all the suspected players and even gave most of them raises. That's interesting. Yes.

44:38 I wonder why. I don't know. Didn't say much about that. He hoped to like quietly move on, I think. Oh, just kind of let's uh forget about that and move along. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Interesting. Um Wow, you didn't even ask how much the raises were. And I had that information too. Don't ask. How much were their raises? Oh, don't ask. How much are the raises? Let me go look. You didn't have it. I did have it. It's just not in my document because it wasn't that important. Now it's the most important part of this episode. Some of them got like what was their overall salary, anyways. Do you ever did you come across that?

45:18 So let's see here. Um, like Eddie Sicott in 1919, his salary was$5,000. Jesus Christ. In 1920, he got a thousand ten thousand dollar range raise. Okay. And then Happy Flesher, his starting salary was three thousand seven hundred and fifty. His 1920 salary was seven seven thousand. Oh, wow. Gandal started at three three thousand five hundred. He actually ended um not signing an additional contract. Oh, how come? Um, I might have it written later. I don't remember. Okay, no worries. Shoeeless Joe Jackson, his salary was six thousand and then 1920 was 8,000.

46:03 Um Fred McMullen, um, his starting salary was 26, and his 1920 salary was 36. Wow, that's really high. 3,600. Okay. Um, Swede Risberg started with uh 3,200 and his 1920 salary was 3200. He actually did not get an additional raise. Gotcha. Buck Weaver started at um 7200 and his 1920 salary was also 7200, did not get a raise. Okay. Um, both of those were multi-year contracts. So yeah, okay. Yeah, yeah. Um Lefty Williams, his starting pay was um$2,600 and 1920 it was six thousand.

46:49 Okay. Isn't that crazy that a baseball player in 1919, 1920 got paid six thousand dollars? I know. But there's there's players now that they get paid like six thousand dollars for like every second they're up on the field or during a game or whatever. It's like what the fuck? Yeah, it's so crazy. So it it appears that Kamisky wanted to move on, better have potentially corrupt stars playing than to ignite a scandal that could tank the franchise as a whole. Sure. One exception though. Oh Chick Gandalf. Yeah, Gandal was offered the same salary as before, no race, which was kind of a Comiskey's way of saying, I don't trust you.

47:32 Right. I think you were the one who was starting all of this, so I don't trust you. And that's the one he was the one that started it, correct? He was. Yeah, he was the the mastermind behind it starting it. So Gandal um refused to sign and instead did opt instead opted to sit out the 1920 season. Oh wow. Um, so this left seven of the White Sox still on the club in 1920, playing as if nothing happened. Okay. And while it looked like it was being swept under the rug, um, and the 1920 season was playing very they were playing very well. Okay, fans mostly forgot about what was going on, and baseball continued. But there were still whispers in the background.

48:13 Of course. Throughout 1920s, rumors dodged the white the dogged the White House whenever something strange happened in a game. Can you resay that all? Throughout the 1920s, rumors like followed the White Sox whenever something strange happened in a game. Okay. Um, so other teams started facing gambling rumors as well. Oh shit, really? Yeah, like if a team was playing badly for some reason, they're like, oh, something's happening. They're throwing the game. Yeah. Wow. When it could have just been a bad day. Yeah, right, of course. And every team has them. Look at our series against the Dodgers. We had a fucking terrible week. Yeah, we did. Let alone a day. So it's not like the Brewers threw it so the Dodgers could get in there. Right.

48:53 Fuck the Dodgers. So the breaking point came in September 1920, nearly a year after the series. Yep, yep. Initially, the catalyst was another suspected fix involving different teams. The Chicago Cubs and the Philadelphia Phillies were rumored to have thrown a regular season game that year. That has never been proven. Okay. Okay. I can see the Cubs doing that. But this prompted authorities in Cook County, Illinois, which is where Chicago is, to convene a grand jury to investigate baseball gambling in general. Oh wow. Once they started digging, the grand jury's attention quickly shifted to the bigger fish, the 1919 World Series.

49:36 Oh boy. At the same time, the White Sox were locked in a tight pennant race in late September 1920. Right. So Charles Kamisky, seeing that things were starting to hamp in, finally did something decisive. And on September 28th, 1920, as the team fought for first place, Kamisky suspended the seven active players who were under suspicion. Oh shit. It was a huge deal. He effectively sacrificed the team's slots at the pennant. Yeah. And Kamisky later had said he had no choice. Sure. By then the scandal was about to explode publicly, and keep the players in the lineup was unjustified.

50:16 Okay. So sure enough, plus some of the players started to crack under pressure. Well, yeah, of course. I mean I'm gonna take another delicious. I mean, it's starting because obviously it's getting back to what they did. It's getting out there. They're like, oh fuck. Yeah. We're supposed to just get some extra money. Yeah. I mean stupid. Just fucking stupid. Yeah. All right, go on. So pitcher Eddie Sicott was the first to come clean. He shocked the grand jury by confessing in detail on September 28th, 1920. Oh, wow. The very next day, shoeless Joe Jackson also testified, admitting to taking money. Yeah.

50:57 And according to press reports, that's when um a young newsboy or a fan supposedly confronted Jackson outside the courthouse, leading to the plea, quote, say it ain't so, Joe. Oh, that's I have, yeah. It it's not super clear if that's actually what happened. Right, but it's very probable or potentially potentially, yeah. Could have happened, yeah. So in any case, by October 1920, the grand jury had heard enough. Oh, sure. It indicted eight White Sox players, as well as several gamblers on charges of conspiracy to defraud the public and throwing baseball games. That's crazy. Notably, yeah, Arnold Rothstein was not indicted.

51:40 Weird. He managed to dist himself, which he originally had planned. Yeah, he he was not a stupid man. So he um there wasn't enough solid evidence evidence to nail him. He even testified to the grand jury denying involvement, and they somehow believed him or were intimidated by him or whatever. Well, we don't know. He was a gangster. Yeah. So the case headed to trial in Chicago in the summer of 1921. Okay. The proceedings began in June and immediately had hiccups as two indiet gamblers didn't show up on time claiming they had illness. Oh, Jesus. So the trial finally got underway in July. Okay. And it was a madhouse. I'm sure it was.

52:20 The courthouse was packed daily with reporters, onlookers, fans. Um, the New York Times described how scores of young boys squeezed to watch, reacting in awe when prosecutors detailed the sellout of the national game. Oh boy. Yeah. Inside the courtroom, the defendants, the ball players were strangely happy. Why? They were they were quite jovial. Look at those whippers snappers. They're all happy and having a good old time. They exchanged friendly banter with members of the current White Sox team who came to watch. Um, current socks even walked over and tickled Buck Weaver in his seat.

53:06 Apparently, Buck Weaver was known to be very, very ticklish. Okay. And they would like randomly just go up and tickle him. That seems causing fits of giggles. Fits of giggles. You can't make this shit up. I mean, you can, but it's not. Crucially, yeah, some evidence had mysteriously vanished before the trial. Weird how that happened sometimes. They were the confessions of Sakat and Jackson gave to the grand jury. They disappeared from the court files. Okay. Rumor had it that someone in the no removed them to weaken the case. Sure. Years later, lo and behold, they were found?

53:48 The missing confessions turned up in the files of Kamiski's own lawyer. Oh. So he was trying to do some shady, shady shit. Yeah. Wow. Yeah. Yeah. How did his lawyer get in there and get those? I mean, he had access to the files. I guess. Yeah. Yeah. I'm not a court person, so I don't know how that all works, especially not 1921. But regardless of how it happened, what happened, the loss of those signed confessions left the prosecution in kind of a ditch. Yeah. Um, as the trial progressed, one of the gambler defendants, sleepy Bill Burns, turned state's evidence.

54:30 Oh. Flipping to testify for the prosecution. Oh, there you go. Burns spilled the beans on the whole plot, implicating the players and detailing meetings with gamblers. Sure. He even tied in Rothstein's name during the testimony. Okay. And one anecdote from the trial, Burns claimed that before one game, Eddie Sicott was so determined to lose that he threatened, quote, to throw the ball clear out of the park if necessary. Despite Burns' testimony and other evidence, the the defense attorneys for the players worked hard to cast doubt. Sure. They painted the accusers and as unreliable crooks and leaned on the lack of physical evidence thanks to those missing confessions.

55:10 Sure. After weeks of testimony, the case went to the jury. And on August 2nd, 1921, the verdict came in. Okay. All eight players and the gamblers on trial with them were acquitted. Really? Acquitted of criminal charges. Not guilty across the board. I never knew that about this. I mean, because it's such a dark spot in baseball history. You just assume, I always assumed that they were found guilty. Really? Yep. Of course, the courtroom erupted in celebration. People were three throwing parties with the jurors. But but the problem is how could you let them play baseball again?

55:55 Oh, just wait. I know. One jury supposedly told a player, happy to have you back next season. Oh, Jesus. It was as if the Black Sox had won a second pennant, basically a vindication, if you will. Right. Um, Chicago's new newspapers even read headlines essentially cheering the outcome, saying, Our boys are innocent. But they're not. Of course, many thought that this is this is bullshit. Well, because it was bullshit. Yeah. The fact that they even got off is just amazing. Yeah. It just tells you what like what you could get through in through the court systems and shit. Yeah. With a little bit of doubt or whatever. It's like clearly they fucking did it. You even had a guy tell the whole fucking story.

56:37 Yeah. But okay. So it's widely suspected that the fixers got off due to a mix of missing evidence, a sympathetic or even a bribe jury. We don't know. I mean, at this point. And then the difficulty of proving the conspiracy beyond a reasonable reasonable doubt. Right, right, right. So legally they were off the hook. Sure. So even before the trial concluded, the powers that be in baseball knew dramat dramatic action. Needed drastic action. There it is. I like dramatic action. Um was needed to salvage the sport's reputation. Right. So the scandal had dominated headlines for months, exposing how deep gambling claws were in the game. Attendance had uh of fans had slumped.

57:17 Really? Um attendance uh the fans were wondering if the whole ser like the whole game was rigged. It was like basically wrestling. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Right. So sensing the gravity of the situation, the team owners had already made a big move in late 1920. Okay. They did away with the old three-man national commission that nominally governed the game and installed a single all-powerful commissioner of baseball. That's when it started, really. I did not know that. So the three-man national commission was night from 1903 to 1920. Okay. It was baseball's first attempt at centralized leadership.

57:59 Sure. No, that makes sense. It was created in 1903 to oversee disputes between the American and the National Leagues. Right. It was made up of American League President Ben Johnson. Okay. National League President John Hid Hedler. Hadler, um, and potentially others. Sure. And a third neutral uh member, usually the Cincinnati Reds owner, Gary Herman. I feel like that's these might be a little biased. Yeah. So it flopped because it was a little bit too political. Ben Johnson and Herman, the Cincinnati Reds owner, were really close. See, yeah, that's unbiased my ass.

58:41 Yeah. So they that it was often skewed to pro-American League. Sure. Um, it had weak enforcement, it had no strong authority over gambling or player conduct, and the 1919 Black Sox scandal exposed its failure. Right. So um for this role, they tapped a um a fiery federal judge known for his no-nonsense rulings. Oh, and Flair for the dramatic. Nice, gotta have that. Judge Kennesaw Mountain Landis. Mountain? Yeah, Kennesaw Mountain Landis. That's a weird name. Apparently, he was named after a Civil War battle. Really?

59:22 That's funny. So it's it's wild to me. I didn't I did not realize I didn't have an actual just commissioner of baseball until until then. 1920. Yeah, so wow, it's only been around a hundred years. Because our old owner, Bud Sealy, was the commissioner. And then he brought the Brewers to from he bought the Seattle Pilots and brought them to Milwaukee. Yeah, they're only around for a year and then they became the Brewers. So So Landis was given unprecedented power, essentially absolute control over the league to do with whatever's necessary to restore the public's trust. In the sport. Yeah. So baseball's owners begged him to be the crusader to save baseball.

1:00:06 Sure. So the day after the acquittal, even as the cleared players were literally popping champagne, command com commissioner Landis said, quote, regardless of the verdict of juries, no player who throws a ball game, no player who undertakes or promises to throw a ball game, no player who sits in conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing a game are discussed and does not promptly tell his club about it will ever play professional baseball again.

1:00:53 Well, I mean, good for him. Oh yeah. Because otherwise this shit can just keep happening. August 3rd, 1921. Landis permanently banned all eight accused White Sox player from organized baseball. That's too just look at the talent that just got fucked. Because of themselves. It was their own fault. Yeah. Don't get me wrong. But damn. So it didn't matter if the court had found them not guilty. In Landis's view, their involvement, even when Buck Weaver just attended the meetings but didn't take any money, it was enough to blacklist them. Yeah, he was he was in on it without being in on it. Yeah. So he was essentially saying baseball would rather lose a few stars and ever risk this kind of scandal again.

1:01:38 For sure. And I mean, look at we're still look at what we have today because of that. Other could have collapsed because of this. Yeah. But wow. So the reaction to Landis's justice was largely positive among the press and fans. Okay. Um, at last, someone was taking a firm stand to clean up the sport. Right. The eight men became baseball's ultimate cautionary examples of being banned for life. Yep. None of them ever played in the majors. They never played in the minors. They never managed. Yeah. Wow. The owner, the other owners and baseball executives backed him fully. Sure. Why wouldn't you?

1:02:18 Yeah. The public was sad to see some of these great players go, but largely understood it was a necessary sacrifice. Of course, yes. Um, Landis would reign as commissioner for 24 years. Oh, wow. His first act was the Black Sox ban. Okay. And it set the tone for the integrity of the game from there on. Sure. Um, the White Sox team was now decimated. Well, yeah. Look at all the people they just lost. They fell from pennant contenders. Sure. Um, Chicago fans were heartbroken and angry. Some directed fury at the players, others at Comiskey for letting it happen. Right. The franchise wouldn't win another American League Championship until 1959, and not another World Series until 2005.

1:03:02 I knew that. Yes. Baseball as a whole moved on relatively quickly. Sure. Um, 1921, 1922, fans started coming back. Um, there were new heroes, um, Babe Ruth. Um by mid-decade of the 1920s, there was like this golden age of baseball. Yeah. Um, owners were relieved that Landis's um decisive action um restored the public faith, essentially. Yeah, of course. Got the fans back in the seats. Yeah. Yeah. Um, one paper wrote after the scandal broke that the 1919 fix was the most brazen conspiracy in the annals of sports, comparing the players are the players to traitorous soldiers who sell out their country.

1:03:50 I mean maybe a little bit different, but along those lines within the that sport, you know, I get that. So with Landis at the helm, they vowed such betrayal would never happen again. And in fact, no World Series has has been accused of being fixed since. Good. There were other scandals for sure. Like Pete Rose. Um, he was he betted on games. Um, there were steroid situations. Yep. But throwing a championship hasn't been on the menu. Good. Shoeless Joe Jackson became the central figure in how the public remembered the Black Sox. That's the one I always do. I didn't know any of these other guys' name, to be honest. Yeah.

1:04:30 So when the scandal first went public, the fans were crushed. No player was more beloved than he was at the time. Right. And the idea that Joe, the central simple country boy, illiterate country boy with this amazing batting talent, had taken dirty money, kind of shook people. Yep. Um, shoeless, shoeless Joe's role in the scandal had always kind of been the gray area. He did take$5,000 of the gambler's money. On the other hand, in the actual games, he did play phenomenally. Right. Um, he never made an error. He had the highest hits or the highest statistics, I guess, so to speak. Right, right. And he maintained that he never wanted to go along with the fix.

1:05:11 He even claimed that he tried to alert Kamisky before the scandal broke. Oh, really? After the series, Jackson says he went to Kamisky asking what to do with the$5,000 and to talk about a possible fix. Oh shit. Excuse me. And Comiskey refused to meet with him. Oh. Joe then wrote Kamisky a letter confessing his suspicions and offering to return the money and got no reply. Okay. So whether Comiskey ignored it deliberately or got lost, we don't know, but Comiskey certainly didn't act on Jackson's attempt to come clean. That's weird. Um, years later, Hall of Famer Ted Williams um rallied um against the injustice, saying Comiskey, quote, covered it up as much as Jackson did, maybe more.

1:05:54 Right. And there's Charles Kamisky in the Hall of Fame, and Shoeless Joe still waits outside, end quote. Yeah, that's sad. So after being banned, Jackson went back to rural Georgia, lived out his days quietly, playing semi-pro ball under aliases, and he ended up running a liquor store. Okay. Over the decades, um, Shoeless Joe turned into a fork folk hero immortalized in um the field of dreams and a novel called Shoeless Joe. Right. Um, to this day, Jackson's name is barred from the Hall of Fame. Yeah, that's too bad. Yeah. So is like Pete Rose. P. Rose just died, so now there's actually talk about maybe letting him in because he's dead.

1:06:35 But like they were he had like a lifetime ban. Yeah. Because of what he did and so don't put him in Hall of Fame. I mean, but the problem You're just glorifying it then. But you're not. In my opinion. The reason why I say that is because he was one of the best hitters ever in baseball. It's called the Hall of Fame. It's all about the stats, what he did with the game. That part sucks, don't get me wrong. It wasn't right. But I feel like he was such a good baseball player. I'm on the side of, well, I could see him being let in there. I'm gonna disagree. That's fine. Because we all know you're wrong. Hey! Be nice. I wasn't being mean.

1:07:18 Most of the other band men faded into obscurity. Sure. Buck Weaver continually protested his innocence, saying that he never took any money. So what, dude? He wrote letters every year to Landis and later commissioners begging for reinstatement to no avail. Right. Um, Gandal, Riseberg, Felsh um bounced around or dropped out of the spotlight. Some gave bitter interviews, blaming Kamiski or the gamblers, never themselves. Sure. Gandalf in 1956 published a tell all article giving his version of events. Like I started it, I did this. Fuck off. Wow. Yes.

1:07:58 So baseball, it has been said that baseball was kind of reborn in the 1920s after the scandal. Um, it did leave a pretty bad mark on American sports, and it's the reason why every ballpark now has a prominent sign warning that any player, umpire, or employee caught gambling on games will be banned for life. That's awesome. Good. Yes. Because fuck that. Kenneshaw Mountain Landis precedent stands, and if even if you're acquitted in court or even if your on-field performance was still good, any involvement in throwing a game means you're out. Yeah. This policy has been enforced again with Pete Rose um in the 1980s. Yep. And the scandal also led to improvements in how baseball was governed.

1:08:41 Okay. So the commissioner's office, born from this chaos, proved effective at centralizing authority. Yeah. Um, the owner owners realized that the perception of honesty was just as important as honesty itself, and they needed the fans to believe in the game again. Right. So they um empowered Lanis to make examples of the Black Sox and anyone else who stepped out of line. Yep. The phrase throwing a game entered the lexicon because of the Black Sox. Okay. And sport sport leagues across America institute their own anti-gambling rules. Sure. It took nearly a hundred years for the White Sox franchises to shake off that that record. Um, and even when the White Sox finally won the World Series again in 2005, articles recalled the ghosts of 1919 and the so-called curse that came from it.

1:09:28 Oh, I think the curse is back in effect because they suck. None of the band players ever got reinstated in their lifetimes. Right. Generations passed, and the Hall of Flame explicitly banned consideration of the players on the ineligible list. Okay. Um, that policy remains, although um, interestingly, all players are long deceased, and there has been occasional discussions about whether to posthumously pardon any of them. Gotcha. Um, so far, no commissioner has ever budged. Why would you at this point? Because that was a shitty thing they did. I mean, it's supposed to be a sport, supposed to be fair, and then you're fucking that up.

1:10:08 So that was the Black Sox scandal. Yeah, it sure was. I mean, obviously I I know about it because of being a baseball fan. I didn't know a lot of that though. Yeah, which is great. So that was kind of fun to learn because of course I knew Shulas Joe Jackson. I didn't know Happy Fels or you know, yeah Chick scandal, yeah, Buck Weaver, all those guys. I didn't I didn't know any of them. I just knew about Joe Jackson, but yeah. Um yeah, that's wild. What a fucked up thing to do. On to Mad Libs. Here we go. It's a summary, basically. In the year 1919, the funny Chicago White Sox, led by star slug slugger Herschel Walker, shat their way into the World Series.

1:10:57 What the fuck? Behind the scenes, a cabal of lemons led by a guy known as Squigglyface were secretly bending with gamblers. The players were tired of their courageous paychecks and decided to throw the series for a mere$362.72. In exchange, they promised to commit drug dealing on the field. There you go. When fans found out, they cried, Wow, and spilled their Mackenzie's black cherry heart cider in disbelief. Sad.

1:11:37 Commissioner Kennesaw Mountain Landis brought the hammer down harder than a battle axe, declaring anyone batting worse than 12 pounds per inch is out for life. 12 pounds per inch. The players now known as the slob face were banned forever. Landis's final words, you should stop doing that. People would like you better. That fits so perfectly.

1:12:20 I just like the you should stop doing that, people. Like you better, my cheeks hurt. Oh well. I suppose. All right, buffoons. That's it for today's episode. Buckle up because we've got another historical adventure waiting for you next time. Feeling hungry for more buffoonery? Or maybe you have a burning question or a wild historical theory for us to explore? Hit us up on social media. We're History Buffoons Podcast on YouTube, X, Instagram, and Facebook. You can also email us at History Buffoons Podcast at gmail.com. We are Bradley and Kate, music by Corey Akers. Follow us wherever you get your podcasts and turn those notifications on to stay in the loop.

1:13:02 Until next time, stay curious and don't forget to rate and review us. Remember, the buffoonery never stops.