The Origin of Weird: Cadaver Synod
Prepare yourself for one of the most surreal and outrageous moments in church history with our latest episode on the Cadaver Synod. Ever wondered how far someone would go for power? Join Kate and Bradley as we promise to unravel the spectacle where the corpse of Pope Formosus was exhumed and put on trial, showcasing the chaotic and comedic lengths of ecclesiastical politics in 9th and 10th century Italy. With the backdrop of a rapidly changing papal lineup and power-hungry Roman factions, we explore how Pope Nicholas I's reforms set the stage for this bizarre event. Follow Formosus's journey from bishop of Porto, Santa Rufina, to a posthumous defendant in a courtroom unlike any other.
Brace yourself for a tale featuring political intrigue, shifting alliances, and the peculiar twist of a deacon speaking for a dead pope. As we navigate the tangled relationships between the papacy, the Spoleto dynasty, Lambert, and Arnulf of Carinthia, we shed light on the motivations behind the Cadaver Synod. Stephen VI's macabre trial backfired spectacularly, sparking public outrage and leading to his demise. Hear how successive popes worked to restore Formosus's reputation and reflect on the absurdity of medieval power struggles with a blend of humor and awe. Tune in for a captivating exploration of this jaw-dropping chapter in church history.
This website contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and purchase a product, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the running of this website and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Please note that I only recommend products and services that I believe in and have personally used or researched.
0:16 oh, hey, there oh hey, there how are you? I am well. How are you'm? good. What are we doing today? on the Origin of. Weird. Okay, this one's really weird. Okay, I hope so. I'm Kate by the way, hello, kate, I am Bradley. We are the History Buffoons Welcome. And this is the Origin of Weird. This is like our I don't know 27th go-around on episodes 28th, something like that, and we're still we're still fucking it up, but that's okay fucking it up since 2024. What up, what up yeah, I mean, we've literally been fucking it up for only what?
0:57 Four months since the release of our first episode. That's alright, though okay, so this one is about cadaver synod. Cadaver synod. Yes, okay, I know what cadavers are. What's synod? You will find out. I cannot wait. That was part of my research. That's a phrase you don't say too, often Wow so this event actually happened to a pope. Oh, pope Formos formosis, does he shit in the woods? He is italian, well then, probably does so what's his name again? Sorry, formosis, pope formosis, that was his pope name.
1:40 Yep, that's a unique one, because usually you get john and, well, all the other ones john, john john and john the second and john the third and john the johns lots of johns anyways. Um, okay, so moses the event that we're going to talk about, um, occurred during a big political upheaval in Italy. Okay. And this was around mid-9th and the mid-10th century, so like for a hundred years, what, what, what, what you said the mid-9th century and the mid-10th century.
2:21 Yes, I'm sorry. For a hundred years I was like what are you talking about? Yes, wow. Well done. Yes, I'm sorry. For a hundred years I was like what are you talking about? Yes, wow. Well done on that one, jesus. Wow, sorry, I'm trying to recover from that. Oh, my word. Okay, go go ahead, keep drinking. I can't Go get a Modelo. What are we doing? Oh Jesus, go get a Modelo. What are we doing? Oh Jesus, go get a Modelo, hold it please, hold it please, and we're back. Hello, modelo, modelo. Okay, between the 9th century and the 10th century, things were changing. So for 100 years. Uh-huh, especially with popes.
3:02 What was changing Specifically? Like their hat or design of that and the cape between 872 and 965. Okay, there were two dozen different popes that's a lot of fucking. Do you know how many two dozen is? and between 896 and 904. So eight years. They had a revolving door of popes, almost one every year. Seriously, yes, what the fuck. There was a lot of confusion going on Pope-ademic.
3:48 Wow, wow, I will, I will. I am not. I am not disappointed in your response to me, saying that that was exactly what I was going for so a lot of powerful roman groups were actually constantly fighting for control, and that's what caused all this chaos. Okay, so roman groups were actually constantly fighting for control and that's what caused all this chaos. Okay, so roman groups were like um influential families and and nobles and even military commanders were like trying to gain control over italy um, unfortunately there wasn't a lot of records at the time, what? so it's kind of hard to get like a full picture of what's actually happening, but I'm gonna give you the the breadcrumbs to put it all together. Oh sweet, I look forward to the breadcrumbs. So Formosus' church career took off in 864.
4:32 864, okay, he became bishop of Porto, santa Rufina. Oh yeah, it's a diocese in Rome. Sure is. Okay, so do you know it. No. Have you Okay, sure is. Okay, so do you know it? No, have you Okay. Gotcha. During Pope Nicholas's the first time. So was he also. It was a pope. Oh, okay, the way you worded it. I'm like, did he have a second time too? No, he's, never mind. He's Pope Nicholas the first Time. That's what threw me off. Sorry, my bad. Oh, this is. This is a very giggly origin, weird and we're not even drunk, okay, no you would think we were, but we're not, we're not okay, um sorry.
5:22 So pope nicholas the first was a really strong leader who wanted to make the Pope even more powerful. Well, why wouldn't he? Because he's going to rule all of the world. So he basically said the Pope was the boss of all other bishops and he tried to limit the power of the kings in church matters. Which didn't? They pretty much, he pretty much. Well, I don't know if he did, but that was pretty much a thing because, like the Pope, he said a lot of shit and if you didn't like it he didn't fucking care. Yeah, yeah. He was, yeah, he was law. I mean, that's again like the whole King Henry thing. I always go back to him. He had to literally leave the church because the Pope's like fuck you man. Yeah, because the Pope's like fuck you man. Yeah, so Pope Nicholas, I also wanted to clean up the church and he was against things like selling church jobs.
6:11 Okay. Like bringing in the public to do church jobs. Oh, so he wanted their own employees, kind of thing. Yeah, and then he was also against priests getting married. Why? Because he wanted them. Never mind, I won't even go there. So Nicholas was also a diplomat. He dealt with powerful rulers like the emperor of the Byzantine Empire Well done and the king of the Franks. The Franks, the Franks. I'll be honest, I did not expect you to get byzantine. I did not expect to get that on the first go if you listen to our last episode, not maybe, maybe not our last episode, but an earlier episode on um, the haymarket affair I said marzell, he say, like I was french yeah, and she.
7:01 There's a couple other words. She also said that were not coherent at all. We're not going to talk about that. Okay, nicholas also had big problems. Yeah, because he had more money. He had a problem with the Sorry. Your laugh was just great, my bad. He had a problem with the leader of the Eastern Church in Constantinople. Oh yeah, do you know who in Constantinople? Yeah, do you know who? Constantinople is now Istanbul. Did you know who that's named after? constantine yeah, girl, yeah, well done so they disagreed about who was actually in charge the eastern church in constantinople or the pope so wait, what was the eastern church?
7:43 it was in constantinople I get where it was. I asked what it was they were fighting over power. Essentially, it's a different. it's not roman catholic or catholic or or whatever, it's just a different church. It's the Eastern versus Western churches. Was this not part of your research? It? was not part of it. So Formosus was actually a really capable and respected guy, and so they put him in charge of the Porto Santa Rufina diocese right. Okay. Two years later, in 866. A year, I remember well he was sent to bulgaria as a special representative of the pope. He was he was pretty good at the job and he was a great diplomat, strong religious leader, and boris the first which was the ruler of bulgaria, okay was so impressed with formosis that he actually asked the pope to make Formosus the Archbishop of Bulgaria.
8:38 Well, shit yeah. Quite the impression he made. They're going through the ranks too. Like hey, the Pope still has power, you know. Right, right, it's a huge deal and Formosus was highly regarded. Okay. But Pope Nicholas said no, what a dick. No, the Pope appointed. And said no, what a dick. No, the pope appointed. Um nope the pope. The pope pointed to an old church rule called the 15th canon of the second council of nicaea council of nicaea. Yes, it basically said a bishop couldn't run more than one church. Oh, and he was already in charge of the porto santa rufina diocese. Okay, yep yep.
9:20 So the idea was to keep things fair and even and spread the power around and not keep. Let one bishop get too powerful yeah, because he didn't want the, the pope, didn't want this bishop to rise up against him. Basically, exactly so. He stuck to the rules and he kept the church quote unquote balanced, balanced. Now now, oh remember, I do revolving door popes okay yep, the popademic, that's amazing, amazing. Sorry didn't mean to derail that, I guess okay. Okay, the pope ademic go so during pope john, the eighth time, and it's okay.
10:06 So it's written down as john pope v, I, I, I, and in parentheses I put eight. Did you have to? Really no, I know what it is, but to make it flow a little better, I put eight next to it and this is flowing fantastically. All right, pope. John Paul VIII. He was in charge in 872 to 882. Okay, so during his time Formosus was in trouble. Why? Because the Pope accused Formosus of conspiring to usurp the papacy. See, like I said, Mm-hmm. So essentially he believed Formosus was plotting to take his place as Pope and he accused Formosus of influencing the Bulgarians against other bishops.
10:54 So basically, this pope was just fucking paranoid. Yeah, he was he was, and it was suggested that Formosus had gained significant influence in Bulgaria and was potentially undermining the authority of the pope and the church, and he was excommunicated. Yeah, just because this pope wanted to live the life he was living, because I'm sure he was taken very well, very well taken care of, I should say. And he was living because I'm sure he was taken very well, very well taken care of, I should say and he was there for 10 years yeah, so he's like I don't want to give this up, man. Yeah, fuck you. Formosa excommunicated so there are different stories about what happened next, right, some say formosis went to a council in troyes, which is a town in France. Okay, very far away from Rome.
11:35 How is that spelled? T-r-o-y-e-s? T-R-O-Y-E-S. Oh, it is Y Okay. Yes, I mean, I could say Troyes, but I thought Troyes sounded better. I don't know. I was just curious, to be honest. So he supposedly promised to never be a priest again. Okay, to never be a priest again, okay. But we're not sure if that was actually true. We don't know right after pope john paul the eighth died, in 1882, so he could have ruled more, but he just died. What year? 882? Did I say 18? Yes? like how do we fast forward a thousand years? god damn it he died in 882 okay, and formosus was able to return then to his job as bishop, and because basically just that pope was just fucking freaking out like man, this guy's coming for my job.
12:24 Yeah, he's like wow what a dick, yeah so um in 891, something interesting happened. What was that? Formosus was elected pope you don't say I did. Actually, at the very beginning were you not there. I was there, I know. Okay, so huge turnaround considering he'd just been exiled. Well, yeah, no kidding. So his election really does show like he was respected in the church well, people liked him clearly, because for one douche pope to excommunicate or exile and whatever and then he comes back within a what? Two years? yeah um, so his problems didn't just disappear because he came back and he's pope now, right?
13:08 Um, there were still accusations from the past pope john the eighth and his excommunication, and it kind of came back to haunt him, I'm sure. Yeah, that shit don't disappear. That's why it's called history. It's always around. As long as someone wrote it down at one point, you're fucked. Formosus was Pope for five years. Okay. So during this time, he formed an alliance with Lambert of Spoleto, which a italian nobleman, and he crowned him as king of italy. Oh wow, but he later saw him as a threat oh geez and shifted his allegiance to arnulf of carinthia, who is a frankish king. Okay, inviting him to invade italy, oh jesus, and challenge lambert's power it's like inviting someone to a party.
13:55 I'd like to invite you to invade this. Yes, what the fuck yeah, there's somebody here I don't like, so I'm going to invite you to come to my house so you can get rid of them. Yeah, so if you could bring an army, yeah. Maybe some cakes, cake, cake I like cake. Cake is good. Lemon. I like lemon cake. Do you know what my favorite cake is? Lemon cake. No, my mom makes it for me every year on my birthday. Carrot cake, oh, carrot cake, so good, okay, cream cheese frosting. Stop, stop. I need my Skittle gummies. I just hit my microphone. Oh, don't do that, all right, anyways, okay gummies I just hit my microphone.
14:35 Oh, don't do that, all right anyways. Okay, so the shift in allegiance angered lambert and led to increased tensions between the papacy and the spoleto dynasty. Sure, and then formosus died in 896. Do you know what he died of? Potentially a stroke, oh dear yes so thus came cadaver synod okay I've got my hands open as if I'm like jazz hands, I'm inviting you, okay? it's really strange okay, it sounds like it's strange so a synod is essentially a council or assembly. Um okay, of a christian denomination, gotcha okay. So held by pope stephen the sixth I didn't write it in parentheses pope stephen six in 897, seven months after formosis died, this synod dug up old accusations against him.
15:34 Against Formosa. Yes, why. It's fucking dead. He was accused of lying under oath. Oh Jesus. Christ and illegally serving as bishop. How, how? These charges probably stem from the fact that the council from the council of Troyes in France? Yeah, because it was said that he promised under oath never to be a priest again, but he came back to be a bishop and then he became the Pope. Oh, so that means he would have broke his promise. Is the Pope a priest? Yes, Is that technically right? Yes, I guess I'd never really put that together for some reason. Yes, so it would mean he broke his promise by becoming a bishop and then the pope, and that's why he was accused of lying, illegally holding office essentially okay, all right, continue so the cadaver synod also wasn't just about the religious issues.
16:29 Um, the pope's support meant a lot back then and it basically gave a ruler legitimacy and power and he had given that power at the time to lambert yeah but formosus got worried about lambert growing power and switched sides. And arnulf of carinthia, who invaded italy, became the emperor okay, okay so these political moves had serious consequences. Lambert and his mother became really powerful in Rome, and historians used to think that Formosus was strongly pro-Carolinian. Okay. Pro-Carolinian and only crowned Lambert because he was forced to.
17:11 So the Carolinians are powerful. Frankish dynasty rose uh, rising from the prominence of the 8th century. Okay, charlemagne. If you've ever heard of charlemagne, he was probably like the most famous of the carolinian rulers can you say that word again, charlemagne? no, the other one you just said carolinian carol carol carol lingian. How is it spelled, carol? linian ing okay ian carol, because I know charlemagne, I, I might be just mixing up things in my brain, but okay, sorry, continue okay so. Um so, charlemagne united the Western Europe under his rule and was crowned emperor by the Pope.
17:57 Okay, so he was a Carolinian. So they were suggesting that Formosus was pro-Carolinian. Okay, okay, so he was a little bit more flexible in his political dealings and he actually had good relations with Lambert for a while, up until what he did until he didn't until the thing until the thing. So things changed when lambert's cousin guy the fourth, of boleto guy the fourth, he got too powerful guy the fourth guy the fourth, um, he was aggressive, he liked conquering people and things and driving out people and that worried Formosus.
18:40 Okay. Okay, so this likely made him seek help from Arnolf. There's a lot of names. And this suggested that his strategy was based on that changing political situation. So, they were just trying to essentially support, with potential evidence why Formosus were making these decisions with Lambert and Arnolf. So by reexamining Formosus' motives, we finally understand a little bit of the shifting alliances that were happening sure so the new perspective helps us see that the cadaver synod wasn't just religious.
19:21 It was actually political and religious conflicts and tensions. Okay, so pope stephen the sixth and I did put that in- wow pope stephen's the sixth actions against the dead Pope. Is it Stephen or? Stephan. It's spelled Stephan. That's Stephen. Yes, I know. But you said Stephan and then you said Stephen. Sorry, I meant Stephen, okay. Pope Stephen VI. His actions against the dead Pope at the Catavra Synod were completely unheard of in the history of the Catholic Church. Okay, so Imagine this A trial. Paint me a picture.
20:03 We're in Italy. That was well done. During the trial, they appointed a deacon to speak for Formosus because he's dead. That's horseshit. You can't have someone else speak for him, even though I understand he's dead. But that's not it. Oh God, have someone else speak for him even though I understand he's dead, but that's not it, oh God. Okay, they dug him up. I've heard of this. They dug up Pope Formosus. And they put him on a chair. Basically right, they propped him up on a throne, like some sort of creepy puppet. Yes, I've heard of this Now that you bring this up.
20:44 I didn't know any of the details, though, but that's fucking fantastic. That is just so weird. This deacon was like talking for this dead pope did he get behind him and go like? I don't know what I'm doing. Move his arms move his head and talk behind him. Did he know his voice like, hey man, yeah, is she on pope for most years? It's like what the fuck I? Oh, that's so great, because I actually I don't remember where I saw this read. It was a brief snippet or something, but again, I didn't know any details. So this is fucking fantastic. Well, well done good. So one of the main charges was that dead Pope Formosus sitting on the throne.
21:24 Yeah. He broke church law by leading more than one church. Oh Jesus. So, Doesn't the Pope lead all churches? Well, he was also. I get that yeah. I understand where you're coming from. Yeah. For sure, for sure, okay, yeah, the second charge was of perjury because they thought he lied about. Yes, he broke his promise um, if he actually did that, then became pope as, like a layman, like I'm just gonna have the title right and then finally pope. That's perjury. Okay, wow, that is staying in. That one was fantastic.
22:05 The last charge was that he presented himself as bishop even though he wasn't so. then that was a huge deal, so. Right. People believe that Formosus shouldn't be Pope, couldn't have been Pope because he had broken his promise and was not a priest. Right, he wasn't, he wasn't, he just was a dude. He essentially like demoted himself Right and then pretended like he wasn't. Huh, so Okay. It would have been a major insult to the church, and the trial was like a crazy mix of the religion and the politics and in the end, formosis was found guilty even though he was already dead so did they hang the corpse?
22:52 I mean? they did desecrate the body. Yeah, was he drawn and quoted. He was stripped of his Pope clothes that he was buried in. Well, yeah, because they're always buried in their final garb or whatever they cut off his fingers because he used those to bless people oh for fuck's sake. And declared everything he did as Pope was completely invalid. Do you think that someone made like a Formosa and finger necklace Ew? What the hell? Maybe you need to be on the origin of weird. You're weird, I'm pretty weird. They essentially wanted to erase him from. They wanted to erase Formosa and everything that he did.
23:35 To make things worse, he didn't even get a proper burial. They buried him in a common grave, just like anybody else. Did they at least mark it? Well, they buried him in a common grave, just like anybody else do they at least mark it? Well, they dug him up again again after they reburied him they tied weights to his body and threw his body into the tiber river. What the fuck, wasn't that brutal? that is and he was so well respected well yeah, and then all these fuckers that thought they were gunning for his job, formosa was like we gotta this fucker's dead, but we gotta make him an example out of this guy. Yeah, so they tied weights to his body and threw him in the river. Yep, what the fuck so the cadaver synod was bizarre, yeah, disturbing, and people were horrified rightly they loved him that, and not only that, they dug the guy up and put him on a chair twice.
24:31 They dug him up twice. No one could believe that stephen the six had done this, and the public outrage led to his downfall he was removed from power, thrown in prison and event. Eventually he was strangled to death oh good, yeah, fuck that guy so the pope who came after stephen vi tried to fix the damage. This was pope theodore ii. Okay, and he had held a council to officially overturn everything that happened at the cadaver synod okay so big step towards restoring formosa's reputation right right and then we have there's so many popes so many popes, popeademic, stop it pope john the ninth um condemned the synod and supported theater.
25:16 The second's decision gotcha okay, so both pope theater, second, and and Pope John IX helped restore Formosa's honor. Okay, so they found his body in the river Formosa's yeah, which had been so horribly treated. Well, right, and they pulled him out and they gave him a proper burial at St Peter's Basilica as a pope. Well, I mean he was a pope. Well, I mean he was a pope. I get, like you got some dumb fucking bitches that are like this guy's gunning for my job, so I gotta fuck up his reputation and stuff. And the only reason why he was exiled or excommunicated or whatever was because this pope thought he was coming for him yeah potential threat.
25:58 So then the only reason why they even got him on anything huge air quotes is because I won't be a priest anymore. But that's just because this dick of a pope fucking said oh man, this guy's gonna take my job and I like this job yeah what a fucking dick. Yeah, so unfortunately, so fortunately, pope sergius the third. What's his name? Sergius s-e-r-g-i-u-s that's a unique one, I don't know but he's three, he's three, he's the third oh my god, that was great he was actually one of the judges at the cadaver synod and he became pope and brought back all the or whole charges against formosis what is wrong with these people?
26:49 just fucking let it go naturally it opened new wounds, old wounds showed how deeply the church was divided like I mean, believe what you want about religion, and to each your own who believe about religion. But these stupid fucks were just about the fucking position yeah, they did not actually care about the church. They just wanted that position because of the power that it came with. You know what a dick so the cadaver Senate is one of the most infamous and shocking events in the history of the Catholic Church. I've never heard about it, but it's fucking wild yeah and it just shows you how much people would go for power in the medieval church.
27:33 Well, yeah, because again it was so respected. There were personal grudges and there were schemes and religious arguments, religious arguments and political arguments and just all ruckus. Yeah, they used Jesus and God's name and their benefit basically is all it was, so it's just weird. Yeah, so that's the cadaver, synod. That's just so weird, so weird. I've never heard of that before. That's just so weird, so weird. I've never heard of that before. I'm pro Formosa. Fuck Stephen and those other fuckers. I mean, what the hell? That's just fucking dumb, yeah.
28:14 But wow, okay, I like that. That was definitely a weird one. Pope, formosa's and his cadaver trial. His cadaver was on the throne. It's just funny because, again, I don't remember where I heard of seeing this. I remember seeing a picture. I'll have to try and look for it after this. I don't know. Yes that's the one. Yep, that's the picture. It's got it all set up for social media. Perfect, because I don't remember how long ago it was, I saw this. I don't even remember what I was looking up. I was looking up something, obviously, and I saw that I'm like that's fucking wild, and all I knew was this pope was dug up to be put on trial.
28:55 Yes, I knew nothing else about what you just said, so that's fantastic to actually have some context behind that picture do you think he was like up in heaven, like on a cloud, like on his belly with his hands under his, his chin and kicking his feet and just watching this bullshit? Go on and be like you know, this doesn't matter, right? pretty funny if you ask me oh shit, they threw my body in the river. What the fuck? I mean, what the hell? and they dug him up twice, twice, and then they took him out of the river. Oh, my word. Yeah. And finally properly buried him. Yeah. Good for him. Yeah, wow, go Formosa, formosis. I think Formosa needs a mimosa.
29:37 Well, I suppose. All right, buffoons. That's it for today's episode. Buckle up, because we've got another historical adventure waiting for you. Next time Feeling hungry for more buffoonery, or maybe you have a burning question or a wild historical theory for us to explore. Hit us up on social media. We're History Buffoons Podcast on YouTube X, instagram and Facebook. You can also email us at historybuffoonspodcast at gmailcom. We are Bradley and Kate. Music by Corey Akers. Follow us wherever you get your podcasts and turn those notifications on to stay in the loop. Until next time, stay curious and don't forget to rate and review us.
30:18 Remember, the buffoonery never stops.
YouTube
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Podcast Addict
RSS Feed
Podchaser