The Origin Of Weird: Ignaz Semmelweis
The shocking story of how simply washing hands could have saved countless women's lives—and why doctors refused to do it.
Meet Ignaz Semmelweis, a Hungarian physician working in Vienna in the 1840s who made a disturbing observation: women were dying at alarming rates after childbirth in doctor-run maternity wards, while those assisted by midwives usually survived. The difference? Doctors were performing autopsies before delivering babies—without washing their hands in between.
When Semmelweis implemented a mandatory hand-washing protocol using chlorinated lime solution in 1847, the results were immediate and dramatic. Mortality rates plummeted from over 18% to near zero within months. Yet instead of celebration, his discovery met with ridicule and hostility from the medical establishment. Many physicians were offended at the suggestion they should wash their hands between procedures, considering it an affront to their status as gentlemen.
The tragic irony of Semmelweis's story is that after years of fighting for acceptance, his mental health deteriorated. In 1865, colleagues tricked him into visiting an asylum where he was forcibly detained. During a struggle with guards, he sustained injuries that became infected, and he died—from the very type of preventable infection he had spent his life fighting—at just 47 years old. His hand-washing practices were largely abandoned, and mortality rates immediately increased sixfold.
Decades would pass before Louis Pasteur and Joseph Lister established germ theory, vindicating Semmelweis's work too late for him to witness. Join us as we explore this heartbreaking medical saga that reminds us how institutional resistance to change can cost countless lives, and how scientific progress sometimes comes at great personal sacrifice.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis
https://www/pbs.org/newshour/health/ignaz-semmelweis-doctor-prescribed-hand-washing
By - Dr. Howard Markel
This website contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and purchase a product, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the running of this website and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Please note that I only recommend products and services that I believe in and have personally used or researched.
0:13 oh, hey there, oh hey there. Where over there, where hello I? am a history buffoon. How about you? hello, I am also a buffoon of history. We are the history buffoons. I'm Bradley. I'm Kate. How are you today, Kate? I'm good, wonderful. This is actually the origin of weird. It sure is. We are trying to find. The weirdest origin stories? Yes, also. Or where did weird start? Yeah, like seriously we don't know, or where did weird start? Yeah, like seriously, we don't know. Did it start with you? I don't know. Did it start with me? I don't know. Let's find out. It most definitely started with you. Do you believe in Sorry?
0:55 That's going to be a running topic for a while. We're going to talk about. Yes, do tell Ignaz Semmelweis, he actually helped prevent a deadly childbirth complication, okay called child bed fever child bed fever. Have you heard of it? I don't think I have. So did the child get a fever in bed? Kind of kind of I mean child bed fever leads me to believe that. It's actually also known as purperol fever, purple fever, purperol, purperol, puperol, puperol, pew, pew, pew, purperol.
1:36 Okay, you need to stop with your fucking variations of this. Childbed fever is a postpartum infection caused by bacteria. Gotcha. Gotcha Okay. So today is largely preventable with proper hygiene and antibiotics, Sure. But back in the day, not so much, not so much. I mean we're talking pre-germ theory, pre-antibiotics. It was a common deadly complication, so that was like common deadly complication. So that was like what Complication, like five years ago? No, what time frame are we talking? The 18th 19th centuries. Okay, I kind of figured that yeah. So, within about three days of giving birth, patients developed abdominal pain fevers.
2:22 So like the mothers did yes, or the babies did, the babies Okay, no fevers. So like the mothers did, yes, or the babies did, the babies. Okay, no the mothers, no the babies. So confused right now. Women. So men were immune. Women. Women. Developed abdominal pain. Yes. Fevers. Okay. Abscesses. Yeah. And other signs of infection, okay, and it would often progress to blood poisoning and death. Sounds fantastic, is that funny? I mean it kind of is because you still didn't answer my question, so it's the mothers. Okay, mortality rates yeah were really high, ranging from 20 to 30 percent for, like, sporadic cases, but then 70 to 80 percent during epidemics holy fuck, so epidemic.
3:15 So is this something that could be caught? then yes, oh wow yes, so many prominent women died from this, including henry the eighth's. So many prominent women died from this, including henry the eighth's wife, jane seymour. I know of her. Yes, yes, she died of childbed fever. Yeah, I did not realize that was her cause of death. Yes, and it was a mystery before evidence-based medicine figured out right what it was, but theories ranged from imbalances in bodily fluids to bad air. Bad air. Yes, like you lived in, never mind Okay. Several factors contributed to the rise of child bed fever epidemics in the 18th and 19th centuries.
3:59 Prior to the 18th century, male doctors rarely delivered babies unless complications came up. Because the women couldn't handle it. No, because they were doctors. No, that's not why. The other kind was midwives. Right so they didn't have that kind of like. No, because midwives were very popular back then. Yes. Yeah, I mean they're still around today, but not as prevalent. So there were two changes that occurred in the 1700s. More women gave birth in hospitals, sometimes due to social programs for the poor. Sure. And these hospitals were staffed by either midwives or doctors.
4:40 Right. And medical education incorporated autopsies more frequently. Right, okay. So more women in hospitals, more autopsies. That's the correlation. Those were the two factors that happened in the 1700s, so these changes had unintended consequences. What's the word Consequences? Consequences. Doctors and students. Can you please say it normally, so I can stop laughing? Consequences. Thank you, consequences.
5:20 Consequences Jesus Christ Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. Consequences Consequences Jesus Christ Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. So doctors and students handled bodies of women who died from child bed fever, often with bare hands. I hope they had to live with dignity. And pathogens weren't understood at the time. So there was a lack of hygiene and hand washing wasn't practiced yet. No. And cervical gloves. Cervical or surgical Surgical gloves, because that would be weird if it was cervical gloves. Surgical gloves. There it is, weren't invented yet.
6:01 It wasn't invented in 1888. Nope, 1889. How were you a year off when you said that I'm tipsy? So surgical gloves weren't invented until 1889. Or, if you're actually proper, 1889. Okay, okay. So the combination of factors led to like a dramatic increase in childbed fever? Okay, okay, so the combination of factors led to like a dramatic increase in childbed fever. Okay. Particularly in hospitals. Right. Several hospitals experienced outbreaks. Hospitals weren't seen as safe places to give birth. Didn't because there was a pretty big mortality rate there, right, huge yeah.
6:41 Like you go to the hospital, you fucking die. You die, yes, which is just wild, because you think you're going to someplace to help you right there, right, huge, yeah, like you go to the hospital. You fucking died a lot of times. Yes, which is just wild, because you think you're going to some place to help you yes, so some doctors recognize the link between autopsies and childbed fever right or patient to patient transmission right, and they did publish their theories and solutions. Okay, so in, so in 1746, Alexander Gordon of Scotland suggested doctors could transmit the disease and recommended disinfectant measures. Isn't it funny? Because they probably in their heads thought there's no way I can transfer that. I'm a doctor. Doctors did believe that.
7:22 Well, some did. I'm sure there's some that did. In 1829, Robert Collins of Dublin implemented chlorine fumigation and cleaning protocols, significantly reducing cases. Isn't that wild? And in 1843, Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr of Boston presented a paper advocating for hand washing and separation of obstetric duties and autopsies Autopsies. Did he? Did he puk the cod Havadjad? He probably did. Oliver Wendell Holmes Senya Senya His paper offered Okay you can stop with that. Practical solutions to prevent child death fever, but it was initially dismissed by the medical community.
8:07 Some doctors ridiculed Holmes' theories. When did we get to the South? When did we get to the South? Why I do declare why I do declare that some doctors ridiculed Holmes theories, can I? get an amen. Amen Attributing to high bed, high child bed fever. Alright, stop, oliver Wendell Holmes Sr. Jesus Christ. His paper offered practical solutions to prevent child bed fever, but it was initially dismissed by the medical community. Some doctors ridiculed Holmes' theories, attributing high childbirth fever rates to just bad luck wow, ignorant fucks that brings me to ignis symbol vice ignis symbol vice okay.
8:58 Idol vice, oh sorry. No symbol vice Edelweiss, oh sorry. Edelweiss no. Semmelweis. Brujaha. He was born on July 1st 1818. Oh, that's a good year. He was the fifth out of ten. Semmelweis studied law first, but then became a doctor in Vienna. Because why not? Because I mean, got nothing else to do. Unable to find work in internal medicine, he pursued obstetrics and in 1846, semmelweis joined the Vienna General Hospital as an assistant in the maternity clinic. The hospital had two clinics, oh. First clinic was staffed by doctors and medical students who also performed autopsies Okay.
9:44 And medical students who also performed autopsies Okay. The second clinic staffed by midwives and their students. Okay. Okay, semmelweis noticed a disturbing difference in childbed fever rates between the clinics, so can I guess the midwife and student one had less. Yes, midwife clinic had 1% to 2% mortality rate, where the doctor's clinic had 5% to 10% mortality rate. That is quite significant. It is, I mean, that's literally. Yeah, that's five times more. Women in labor would plead to be admitted to the midwife's clinic or giving birth on the street rather than the doctor's clinic.
10:29 Isn't that fucking wild? Yes, that's just. Some of us even noticed that the street births had lower motility rates. See, that is just fucking amazing. Yes, because you can't tell me those were cleanly, cleanly. No, I mean, there was no godliness going on there, no, there wasn't. Yes Because you can't tell me those were cleanly, cleanly, no. I mean, there was no godliness going on there? No, there wasn't, wow Okay. He was deeply disturbed. Can you blame him by this investigation? I? don't blame him. Yeah, you don't say. He excluded overcrowding as a cause, since the second clinic was always more crowded. Sure because more people wanted to go there. He eliminated climate because the two clients were in close proximity to each other.
11:14 He altered the position in which mothers gave birth. So instead of on their back on their knees. Or side-lying or something like that. He proposed that priests giving less rights in the clinic were terrifying women after birth, causing them to develop the fever, Like they would hear that the priest was here with his bell ringing. Bring out your dead. Exactly Women would hear that and potentially panic, thinking that it was them. Yeah, they were dying. Yeah, Okay. So a turning point came, when his colleague Caleb nope, Jacob Kolechka, Kolechka.
11:55 Died of a condition resembling child bed fever after an autopsy mishap. Okay. A student had poked him with a scalpel. After cutting into. Yes, the autopsy yes. The disease. Yes, wow, so Semmelweis noticed that so how do you actually just poke him with a fucking scalpel Like oh hey, doc, yeah, wow, that's fucked up, yeah, okay. So Semmelweis noticed that, unlike midwives, medical students routinely performed autopsies and vaginal examinations. Because those go side by side. So he theorized that cadaverous particles from autopsies were transmitted to patients by the doctor's hands.
12:40 Yeah, because you know they're fucking dead Icky. Yeah, continue Sorry. Icky, icky, icky. Icky icky eh. In May 1847, he implemented a mandatory hand washing protocol. Which is probably thought fucking witchcraft at the time. Yeah, it was chlorinated lime solution. I said wine Wine Chlorinated lime solution. I said wine Wine Chlorinated lime solution, which was a disinfectant after autopsies, gotcha. So he did this because he found the chlorinated solution worked best to remove the putrid smell of infected autopsy tissue.
13:21 And it's funny because that was the initial reason for it was just to get rid of the smell, not to actually clean your hands. It was just to eliminate a smell, right, and it destroyed the poisonous or contaminating cadaveric agent hypothetically being transmitted by this material. But the impact was immediate. Child bed fever mortality in the doctor's clinic plummeted from 18.3 percent in april to 2.2 percent in june I mean, that's literally two months, yes, and it drops 16 percent, yes, and by august, another two months later, zero deaths, for the first time since autopsies became routine weird, isn't it?
14:08 despite the success of hand washing, he couldn't fully explain why hand washing worked, leading to doubts of his theory. So he revised his theory, suggesting that cadaverous particles could come from any decaying matter, not just human bodies. Right, so most established doctors rejected his findings. They clung on to the miasma theory, which is disease caused by bad air those people are, I understand, not enough information. Yeah fuck, they're dumb some doctors were offended at the suggestion that they should wash their hands.
14:48 I know better. Like you think, I put my hands somewhere they shouldn't have been. I am a doctor, I'm a gentleman doctor. Yeah, I do declare, sir, my hands are clean, sir. By all means. I believe you are wrong. But access to clean water wasn't always guaranteed in here. Well, she took time, that is true, that is true. So Semmelweis documented the continued high child bed fever rates and attacks on his theories. So, despite the resistance, semmelweis powered the fuck through, symbolized powered the fuck through.
15:32 So in 1848 he mandated cleaning birthing instruments with chlorinated lime, further reducing mortality rates weird. With a constant rejection he faced, he became increasingly frustrated and combative well, because people kept going against what he was saying, even though the results were fucking proving them. Mm-hmm, so cool. So in 1849, he had like a two-year contract with this hospital and it ended and the hospital offered him a position without a cadaver contract. Okay, and he felt sour about that offered him a position without a cadaver contract. Okay, and he felt sour about that. He left Vienna for Hungary in 1850 without a farewell.
16:12 He was just like I'm out. Adios, au revoir. Uh-huh, and in 1851, he became head of obstetrics at St Ruckus Hospital, which was an honorary position, and he achieved lower childbed fever rates. And for everyone who doesn't know what obstetrics is it's baby delivery. Yeah, yes, but he virtually eliminated the disease. Weird. I mean, it seems coincidental. There's no way he could have been part of this. During 1851 to 1855, only eight patients died from childbed fever.
16:53 Yeah, weird. Out of 933 births. That's pretty good fucking odds. Eight in four years. I mean that's two a year. Out of 933 births. So 933 births four years. I mean that's over 200 births a year out of 933 births. So 933 births four years. I mean that's over 200 births a year and you lost two per year. That's pretty fucking good. I mean, there's today. We'll probably lose that, yeah, honestly, from other complications of course not from what we're talking about, but still that's pretty good, fucking odds so, even though some devices, hand washing methods, dramatically reduce these deaths, they weren't exactly a hit.
17:34 Well, no, because people had to do an extra step. Yeah, and they're like but but, sir, I'm a doctor the leading doctor at the university of pest In Budapest. His name is ED Burley. He clung to the belief that childbirth fever came from unclean bowels. Not unclean air, no bowels. He upgraded his theory. His cure was harsh purges. Of the buttocks. Which, you can imagine, isn't exactly pleasant. No, so he had basically given him a colonoscopy. Enemas. That's the word I was looking for. Nasty harsh purging enemas. There's a really good tool song called Enema, anyways.
18:16 Okay. So Burley finally kicked the bucket in 1854 and Semmelweis saw his chance to become a new professor. Ooh, Unfortunately, an old rival from Vienna named Karl Braun also applied. But Braun, despite not even speaking Hungarian, won the favor of the Hungarian doctors and got the job. However, Samuel Weiss was not going to give up easily. Something Weiss. Thanks to some intervention from Vienna, the vote was overturned and eventually he landed the position in 1855. You wouldn't know it, but his hand-washing protocols once again brought impressive results.
19:00 Weird. I mean, it just seems to be a proven fucking thing, but okay. Despite his success, Semmelweis turned down an offer to become a professor in zurich in 1857 okay maybe he was tired of fighting the medical establishment, or maybe he just found love, because that seemed. He married a woman oh yes, and they had a family of five children oh, wow despite the success of hand Semmelweis' abrasive personality and hostage tactics backfired. Yeah, he didn't go about it the right way In 1861, semmelweis published a book about his handwashing discoveries and unfortunately some foreign reviews weren't exactly glowing.
19:41 Of course. Feeling defeated, frustrated, Semmelweis lashed out at his critics in a series of very angry open letters. Because they didn't have emails back then. He called prominent doctors names like irresponsible murderers and ignoramuses. Oh, not the ignoramus. That's the worst. That cuts you to the quick right there. And he challenged them to like a public debate, demanding they all convert to his theory. Okay, challenged them to like a public debate, demanding they all convert to his theory. Around the same time, semmelweis' behavior started to raise eyebrows. He became increasingly withdrawn from his family, spending more time away, sometimes with a prostitute, and his wife noticed changes in his personality.
20:24 So is there any like speculation as to why? So it was suggested that he had early onset Alzheimer's. Oh. Yes. So there could have been something there, just not 100% exactly what it was. They also think it could have been syphilis. I was going to say that actually. And some believe it was emotional burnout from years of stress, of fighting for acceptance. I mean, I understand that, but it seems a little more than that, but okay. In 1865, semmelweis' mental state deteriorated. Yep, a colleague tricked him into visiting a mental asylum under false pretenses.
21:04 That's bullshit. And there Semmelweis realized his situation and attempted to escape. That's bullshit. That seems really helpful, oh my God. Well, yeah, two weeks later, semmelweis died at the age of 47. Well, yeah. From a gangrenous wound, likely caused by an infection, during his struggle with the guards. Irony is, he died of an infection that was preventable with proper care.
21:45 Yep, wow, that's horseshit. Semmelweis's work, though unrecognized in his lifetime, laid the groundwork for the future. For modern day. yeah, yes, so immediately. Mortality rates increased sixfold. Yeah, because no one fucking cared about his shit. This fucker's gone. He's not preaching his shit. Let's go back to our old ways. And all of a sudden, lots more people died. The physicians of Budapest did nothing, said nothing, no inquiries, no protests, Wow that's bullshit, and almost no one, either in Vienna or Budapest, seems to have been willing to acknowledge Semmelweis' life and work.
22:25 That's terrible. It wasn't until the 1880s, after the work of Pasteur and Lister, that infection control became standard in obstetrics. Okay, but these researchers were unaware of Semmelweis' contributions. Of course. Why would they know that? Yeah, honestly. Semmelweis' story wasn't fully recognized until the late 19th century. Wow, that's wild. It's weird, it is because you would think it's. I mean, obviously, in our day and age it's such a simple thing. Wash your fucking hands. Wash your hands. Simple as that. Yeah, and obviously there's a little. There's more to it, obviously, with the cleaning of the utensils and supplies and such and whatever.
23:07 But like, literally, just wash your fucking hands and they're like I'm a doctor, sir, I do not have to wash my hands, my reputation is clean, but your hands aren't, you fuck. You just touch a dead body, yeah. You literally touch a decaying fucking body. Let's go check this chick's vagina out. And have a baby. Yeah, and that's going to fucking go well. No one said ever Unless you're from that fucking time and you're a fucking idiot. I mean, I get it, things evolve, practices come into play and so on and whatever, but it's like wash your fucking hands, man, for the love of God.
23:50 Well, that was Ignaz Semmelweis and his chlorinated lime treatment. He was a fucking pioneer. He was a pioneer. He really was in the terms of cleanliness and I'd have to say godliness. Well, I suppose. All right, buffoons. That's it for today's episode. Buckle up, because we've got another historical adventure waiting for you. Next time Feeling hungry for more buffoonery, or maybe you have a burning question or a wild historical theory for us to explore. Hit us up on social media. We're History Buffoons Podcast on YouTube X, instagram and Facebook. You can also email us at historybuffoonspodcast at gmailcom.
24:32 We are Bradley and Kate. Music by Corey Akers. Follow us wherever you get your podcasts and turn those notifications on to stay in the loop. Until next time, stay curious and don't forget to rate and review us. Remember the buffoonery never stops. Love it, love it, Love it.
YouTube
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Podcast Addict
RSS Feed
Podchaser